Reviews: Dialog-based Interactive Image Retrieval

Update: Thank you for your feedback. Given your comments as well as the discussion with the other reviewers I have slightly adjusted my score to be more positive. I still stand by my comments below in that I think the work is interesting, but that the presentation in its current form is misleading. Assuming the paper will be accepted, I implore you to reconsider the presentation of this work, particularly with respect to claiming that this is a fully fledged dialogue system. The idea that the last image chosen represents a distillation of all previous rounds of dialogue is fanciful.