Reviews: Generalizing Tree Probability Estimation via Bayesian Networks

In this paper the authors propose an efficient method for tree probability estimation (given a collection of trees) that relies on the description of trees as subsplit Bayesian networks. Through this representation, the authors relax the classic conditional clade distribution - which assumes that given their parent, sister clades are independent - and assume instead that given their parent subsplit, sister subsplits are independent, thus allowing more dependence structure on sister clades. The authors first present a simple maximum likelihood estimation algorithm for rooted trees, and then propose two alternatives to generalize their work to unrooted trees. They finally illustrate their method on both simulated and real-data experiments. I think this paper is very well written, in particular I have greatly appreciated the Background and SBN description sections that make use of a simple though not trivial example to introduce new notions and provide useful insights on the assumptions.