Review for NeurIPS paper: Promoting Coordination through Policy Regularization in Multi-Agent Deep Reinforcement Learning

Summary and Contributions: Based on rebuttal and discussion: Upon reading all reviews, I recognize that we agree the article is well presented, and I stand by the concerns I raised. Note that I primarily criticized the absence of some relevant context in the original submission (which the authors admit in their rebuttal), rather than the contribution itself (albeit it may be smaller than proclaimed). Their refutation of it being a planning setting is fair. While I maintain that it is a self-play setting, this is implied by CTDE and thus not necessary to state again. A stale flavor remains from overselling their contribution's novelty in the introduction [L36-45].