Reviews: Bayesian Model Selection Approach to Boundary Detection with Non-Local Priors

Neural Information Processing Systems 

Update: I downgrade my review to 5. The main concern is 1) Some more extensive simulations will make the results more convincing, as the numerical experiment is the only way to assess the performance of the proposed priors. It might take a major revision to reflect such comprehensive comparisons. With that being said, I believe the paper does contain interesting results that are novel and useful to the community. In particular, the theoretical results seem sound, and the paper is fairly readable. But I think there is also room for improvement.