Review for NeurIPS paper: Evidential Sparsification of Multimodal Latent Spaces in Conditional Variational Autoencoders
–Neural Information Processing Systems
Weaknesses: I find three points of weakness that decrease the potential impact of the work: i) References are too focused on "application" papers and evidential theory, while authors want to present a new methodology for reducing the discrete latent space dimensionality in auto-encoders. Well, if authors include more references or comments about theoretical papers of VAEs, this work could be better contrasted with other similar works, and will potentially facilitate its disclosure.. ii) Apart from the references, authors fail on the fact of not including a short paragraph or subsection about the CVAE with a few details to refresh the ideas and having a work that is totally self-contained. They could have sacrificed half-page of experiments to described the conditional auto-encoder better. So, if the number 9 was badly compressed in the latent space, and then so many other dimensions removed, after re-normalising, the number 9 gets importance? is that what is happening? The other question is about Table 1 and the accuracy performance under the 50% in classification, pretty bad, right?
Neural Information Processing Systems
Jan-25-2025, 19:32:20 GMT
- Technology: