Review for NeurIPS paper: Efficient Clustering Based On A Unified View Of K-means And Ratio-cut

Neural Information Processing Systems 

Additional Feedback: EDIT: I am satisfied by the response of the reviewers that they will address the issues of clarity, after which I believe the paper represents a valuable contribution. I commend the authors for what appears to be an innovative algorithm with extremely good practical performance. I believe the paper could be a very influential one, but I feel the presentation of the work needs to be modified and improved. I think there are a few too many concessions which are made. For example, you begin with ratio cut, then change to normalised cut when you assert that the affinity matrix is made doubly stochastic.