Logic & Formal Reasoning
Answer Set Planning: A Survey
Son, Tran Cao, Pontelli, Enrico, Balduccini, Marcello, Schaub, Torsten
Answer Set Planning refers to the use of Answer Set Programming (ASP) to compute plans, i.e., solutions to planning problems, that transform a given state of the world to another state. The development of efficient and scalable answer set solvers has provided a significant boost to the development of ASP-based planning systems. This paper surveys the progress made during the last two and a half decades in the area of answer set planning, from its foundations to its use in challenging planning domains. The survey explores the advantages and disadvantages of answer set planning. It also discusses typical applications of answer set planning and presents a set of challenges for future research.
Learning Temporal Rules from Noisy Timeseries Data
Samel, Karan, Zhao, Zelin, Chen, Binghong, Li, Shuang, Subramanian, Dharmashankar, Essa, Irfan, Song, Le
Events across a timeline are a common data representation, seen in different temporal modalities. Individual atomic events can occur in a certain temporal ordering to compose higher level composite events. Examples of a composite event are a patient's medical symptom or a baseball player hitting a home run, caused distinct temporal orderings of patient vitals and player movements respectively. Such salient composite events are provided as labels in temporal datasets and most works optimize models to predict these composite event labels directly. We focus on uncovering the underlying atomic events and their relations that lead to the composite events within a noisy temporal data setting. We propose Neural Temporal Logic Programming (Neural TLP) which first learns implicit temporal relations between atomic events and then lifts logic rules for composite events, given only the composite events labels for supervision. This is done through efficiently searching through the combinatorial space of all temporal logic rules in an end-to-end differentiable manner. We evaluate our method on video and healthcare datasets where it outperforms the baseline methods for rule discovery.
Complexity of Arithmetic in Warded Datalog+-
Berent, Lucas, Nissl, Markus, Sallinger, Emanuel
Warded Datalog+- extends the logic-based language Datalog with existential quantifiers in rule heads. Existential rules are needed for advanced reasoning tasks, e.g., ontological reasoning. The theoretical efficiency guarantees of Warded Datalog+- do not cover extensions crucial for data analytics, such as arithmetic. Moreover, despite the significance of arithmetic for common data analytic scenarios, no decidable fragment of any Datalog+- language extended with arithmetic has been identified. We close this gap by defining a new language that extends Warded Datalog+- with arithmetic and prove its P-completeness. Furthermore, we present an efficient reasoning algorithm for our newly defined language and prove descriptive complexity results for a recently introduced Datalog fragment with integer arithmetic, thereby closing an open question. We lay the theoretical foundation for highly expressive Datalog+- languages that combine the power of advanced recursive rules and arithmetic while guaranteeing efficient reasoning algorithms for applications in modern AI systems, such as Knowledge Graphs.
Giordano
Temporal logics can be used in reasoning about actions for specifying constraints on domain descriptions and temporal properties to be verified. In this paper, we exploit Bounded Model Checking (BMC) techniques in the verification of Dynamic Linear Time Temporal Logic (DLTL) properties of an action theory, which is formulated in a temporal extension of Answer Set Programming (ASP). To achieve completeness, we propose an approach to BMC which exploits the Buechi automaton construction while searching for a counterexample. We provide an encoding in ASP of the temporal action domain and of Bounded Model Checking of DLTL formulas.
Gebser
The advance of Internet and Sensor technology has brought about new challenges evoked by the emergence of continuous data streams. While existing data-stream management systems allow for high-throughput stream processing, they lack complex reasoning capacities. We address this shortcoming and elaborate upon an approach to knowledge-intense stream reasoning based on Answer Set Programming (ASP). The emphasis thus shifts from rapid data processing to complex reasoning. To accommodate this in ASP, we develop new techniques that allow us to formulate problem encodings dealing with emerging as well as expiring data in a seamless way. We thus propose novel language constructs and modeling techniques for specifying and reasoning with time-decaying logic programs.
Feier
The paper introduces a worst-case optimal tableau algorithm for reasoning with Forest Logic Programs, a decidable fragment of Open Answer Set Programming. FoLPs are a useful device for tight integration of the Description Logic and the Logic Programming worlds: reasoning with the DL SHOQ can be simulated within the fragment. The algorithm reuses a knowledge compilation technique previously introduced, but improves on previous results by decreasing the worst-case running time with one exponential level. The decrease in complexity is due to the usage in conjunction of a new redundancy and of a new caching rule.
Febbraro
Answer Set Programming (ASP) is a fully-declarative logic programming paradigm, which has been proposed in the area of knowledge representation and non-monotonic reasoning. Nowadays, the formal properties of ASP are well-understood, efficient ASP systems are available, and, recently, ASP has been employed in a few industrial applications. However, ASP technology is not mature for a successful exploitation in industry yet; mainly because ASP technologies are not integrated in the well-assessed development processes and platforms which are tailored for imperative/object-oriented programming languages. In this paper we present a new programming framework blending ASP with Java. The framework is based on JASP, an hybrid language that transparently supports a bilateral interaction between ASP and Java. JASP specifications are compliant with the JPA standard to perfectly fit extensively-adopted enterprise application technologies. The framework also encompasses an implementation of JASP as a plug-in for the Eclipse platform, called JDLV, which includes a compiler from JASP to Java. Moreover, we show a real-world application developed with JASP and JDLV, which highlights the effectiveness of our ASP–Java integration framework.
Dubois
Possibilistic logic is a well-known logic for reasoning under uncertainty, which is based on the idea that the epistemic state of an agent can be modeled by assigning to each possible world a degree of possibility, taken from a totally ordered, but essentially qualitative scale. Recently, a generalization has been proposed that extends possibilistic logic to a meta-epistemic logic, endowing it with the capability of reasoning about epistemic states, rather than merely constraining them. In this paper, we further develop this generalized possibilistic logic (GPL). We introduce an axiomatization showing that GPL is a fragment of a graded version of the modal logic KD, and we prove soundness and completeness w.r.t. a semantics in terms of possibility distributions. Next, we reveal a close link between the well-known stable model semantics for logic programming and the notion of minimally specific models in GPL. More generally, we analyze the relationship between the equilibrium logic of Pearce and GPL, showing that GPL can essentially be seen as a generalization of equilibrium logic, although its notion of minimal specificity is slightly more demanding than the notion of minimality underlying equilibrium logic.
Doherty
Complex mission or task specification languages play a fundamentally important role in human/robotic interaction. In realistic scenarios such as emergency response, specifying temporal, resource and other constraints on a mission is an essential component due to the dynamic and contingent nature of the operational environments. It is also desirable that in addition to having a formal semantics, the language should be sufficiently expressive, pragmatic and abstract. The main goal of this paper is to propose a mission specification language that meets these requirements. It is based on extending both the syntax and semantics of a well-established formalism for reasoning about action and change, Temporal Action Logic (TAL), in order to represent temporal composite actions with constraints. Fixpoints are required to specify loops and recursion in the extended language. The results include a sound and complete proof theory for this extension. To ensure that the composite language constructs are adequately grounded in the pragmatic operation of robotic systems, Task Specification Trees (TSTs) and their mapping to these constructs are proposed. The expressive and pragmatic adequacy of this approach is demonstrated using an emergency response scenario.
Vlaeminck
Many examples of epistemic reasoning in the literature exhibit a stratified structure: defaults are formulated on top of an incomplete knowledge base. These defaults derive extra information in case information is missing in the knowledge base. In autoepistemic logic, default logic and ASP this inherent stratification is not preserved as they may refer to their own knowledge or logical consequences. Defining the semantics of such logics requires a complex mathematical construction. As an alternative, this paper further develops ordered epistemic logic.