Constraint-Based Reasoning
A Comparison of Lex Bounds for Multiset Variables in Constraint Programming
Law, Yat Chiu (The Chinese University of Hong Kong) | Lee, Jimmy Ho Man (The Chinese University of Hong Kong) | Woo, May Hiu Chun (The Chinese University of Hong Kong) | Walsh, Toby (NICTA and the University of New South Wales)
Set and multiset variables in constraint programming have typically been represented using subset bounds. However, this is a weak representation that neglects potentially useful information about a set such as its cardinality. For set variables, the length-lex (LL) representation successfully provides information about the length (cardinality) and position in the lexicographic ordering. For multiset variables, where elements can be repeated, we consider richer representations that take into account additional information. We study eight different representations in which we maintain bounds according to one of the eight different orderings: length-(co)lex (LL/LC), variety-(co)lex (VL/VC), length-variety-(co)lex (LVL/LVC), and variety-length-(co)lex (VLL/VLC) orderings. These representations integrate together information about the cardinality, variety (number of distinct elements in the multiset), and position in some total ordering. Theoretical and empirical comparisons of expressiveness and compactness of the eight representations suggest that length-variety-(co)lex (LVL/LVC) and variety-length-(co)lex (VLL/VLC) usually give tighter bounds after constraint propagation. We implement the eight representations and evaluate them against the subset bounds representation with cardinality and variety reasoning. Results demonstrate that they offer significantly better pruning and runtime.
Solving Difficult CSPs with Relational Neighborhood Inverse Consistency
Woodward, Robert J. (University of Nebraska-Lincoln) | Karakashian, Shant (University of Nebraska-Lincoln) | Choueiry, Berthe Y. (University of Nebraska-Lincoln) | Bessiere, Christian (University of Montpellier)
Freuder and Elfe (1996) introduced Neighborhood Inverse Consistency (NIC) as a strong local consistency property for binary CSPs. While enforcing NIC can significantly filter the variables domains, the proposed algorithm is too costly to be used on dense graphs or for lookahead during search. In this paper, we introduce and characterize Relational Neighborhood Inverse Consistency (RNIC) as a local consistency property that operates on the dual graph of a non-binary CSP. We describe and characterize a practical algorithm for enforcing it. We argue that defining RNIC on the dual graph unveils unsuspected opportunities to reduce the computational cost of our algorithm and increase its filtering effectiveness. We show how to achieve those effects by modifying the topology of the dual graph, yielding new variations the RNIC property. We also introduce an adaptive strategy to automatically select the appropriate property to enforce given the connectivity of the dual graph. We integrate the resulting techniques as full lookahead strategies in a backtrack search procedure for solving CSPs, and demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach for solving known difficult benchmark problems.
Inner Regions and Interval Linearizations for Global Optimization
Trombettoni, Gilles (INRIA, I3S, Université) | Araya, Ignacio (Nice-Sophia) | Neveu, Bertrand (UTFSM) | Chabert, Gilles (Imagine, LIGM, Université)
Researchers from interval analysis and constraint (logic) programming communities have studied intervals for their ability to manage infinite solution sets of numerical constraint systems. In particular, inner regions represent subsets of the search space in which all points are solutions. Our main contribution is the use of recent and new inner region extraction algorithms in the upper bounding phase of constrained global optimization. Convexification is a major key for efficiently lower bounding the objective function. We have adapted the convex interval taylorization proposed by Lin and Stadherr for producing a reliable outer and inner polyhedral approximation of the solution set and a linearization of the objective function. Other original ingredients are part of our optimizer, including an efficient interval constraint propagation algorithm exploiting monotonicity of functions. We end up with a new framework for reliable continuous constrained global optimization. Our interval B&B is implemented in the interval-based explorer Ibex and extends this free C++ library. Our strategy outperforms the best reliable global optimizers.
On the Discovery and Utility of Precedence Constraints in Temporal Planning
Hu, Yanmei (Northeast Normal University) | Yin, Minghao (Northeast Normal University) | Cai, Dunbo (Wuhan Institute of Technology)
We extend the precedence constraints contexts heuristic (hpcc) to a temporal and numeric setting, and propose rules to account precedence constraints among comparison variables and logical variables. Experimental results on benchmark domains show that our extension has the potential to lead to better plan quality than that with the heuristic proposed by Eyerich and others.
Conflict-Driven Constraint Answer Set Solving with Lazy Nogood Generation
Drescher, Christian (NICTA and University of New South Wales) | Walsh, Toby (NICTA and University of New South Wales)
Drescher and Walsh, to satisfiability modulo theories, the key idea is to incorporate 2010). Then, constraint answer sets of the resulting program theory-specific predicates into propositional formulas, can be characterized via Boolean assignments over and extending an ASP solver's decision engine for a atom(Π) body(Π) that do not violate a set of nogoods more high-level proof procedure. A promising approach to imposed by Π. Formally, a Boolean assignment A is a sequence constraint answer set programming (CASP) has been presented (σ
Extensible Automated Constraint Modelling
Akgun, Ozgur (University of St. Andrews) | Miguel, Ian (University of St. Andrews) | Jefferson, Chris (University of St. Andrews) | Frisch, Alan M. (University of York) | Hnich, Brahim (Izmir University of Economics)
In constraint solving, a critical bottleneck is the formulation of aneffective constraint model of an input problem. The Conjure system describedin this paper, a substantial step forward over prototype versions of Conjurepreviously reported, makes a valuable contribution to the automation ofconstraint modelling by automatically producing constraint models from theirspecifications in the abstract constraint specification language Essence. Aset of rules is used to refine an abstract specification into a concreteconstraint model. We demonstrate that this set of rules is readily extensibleto increase the space of possible constraint models Conjure can produce. Ourempirical results confirm that Conjure can reproduce successfully the kernelsof the constraint models of 32 benchmark problems found in the literature.
The Next Best Solution
Brafman, Ronen (Ben Gurion University) | Pilotto, Enrico (University of Padova) | Rossi, Francesca (University of Padova) | Salvagnin, Domenico (University of Padova) | Venable, Kristen Brent (University of Padova) | Walsh, Toby (University of New South Wales and NICTA)
We study the computational complexity of finding the next most preferred solution in some common formalisms for representing constraints and preferences. The problem is computationally intractable for CSPs, but is polynomial for tree-shaped CSPs and tree-shaped fuzzy CSPs. On the other hand, it is intractable for weighted CSPs, even under restrictions on the constraint graph. For CP-nets, the problem is polynomial when the CP-net is acyclic. This remains so if we add (soft) constraints that are tree-shaped and topologically compatible with the CP-net.
Distributed Constraint Optimization Under Stochastic Uncertainty
Léauté, Thomas (Ecole Polytechnique Federale de Lausanne (EPFL)) | Faltings, Boi (Ecole Polytechnique Federale de Lausanne (EPFL))
In many real-life optimization problems involving multiple agents, the rewards are not necessarily known exactly in advance, but rather depend on sources of exogenous uncertainty. For instance, delivery companies might have to coordinate to choose who should serve which foreseen customer, under uncertainty in the locations of the customers. The framework of Distributed Constraint Optimization under Stochastic Uncertainty was proposed to model such problems; in this paper, we generalize this formalism by introducing the concept of evaluation functions that model various optimization criteria. We take the example of three such evaluation functions, expectation , consensus , and robustness , and we adapt and generalize two previous algorithms accordingly. Our experimental results on a class of Vehicle Routing Problems show that incomplete algorithms are not only cheaper than complete ones (in terms of simulated time , Non-Concurrent Constraint Checks , and information exchange) , but they are also often able to find the optimal solution. We also show that exchanging more information about the dependencies of their respective cost functions on the sources of uncertainty can help the agents discover higher-quality solutions.
A Short Introduction to Preferences: Between AI and Social Choice
Rossi, Francesca, Venable, Kristen Brent, Walsh, Toby
Computational social choice is an expanding field that merges classical topics like economics and voting theory with more modern topics like artificial intelligence, multiagent systems, and computational complexity. This book provides a concise introduction to the main research lines in this field, covering aspects such as preference modelling, uncertainty reasoning, social choice, stable matching, and computational aspects of preference aggregation and manipulation. The book is centered around the notion of preference reasoning, both in the single-agent and the multi-agent setting. It presents the main approaches to modeling and reasoning with preferences, with particular attention to two popular and powerful formalisms, soft constraints and CP-nets. The authors consider preference elicitation and various forms of uncertainty in soft constraints.
Pairwise Decomposition for Combinatorial Optimization in Graphical Models
Favier, Aurélie (Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique) | Givry, Simon de (Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique) | Legarra, Andrès (Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique) | Schiex, Thomas (Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique)
We propose a new additive decomposition of probability tables that preserves equivalence of the joint distribution while reducing the size of potentials, without extra variables. We formulate the Most Probable Explanation (MPE) problem in belief networks as a Weighted Constraint Satisfaction Problem (WCSP). Our pairwise decomposition allows to replace a cost function with smaller-arity functions. The resulting pairwise decomposed WCSP is then easier to solve using state-of-the-art WCSP techniques. Although testing pairwise decomposition is equivalent to testing pairwise independence in the original belief network, we show how to efficiently test and enforce it, even in the presence of hard constraints. Furthermore, we infer additional information from the resulting nonbinary cost functions by projecting and subtracting them on binary functions. We observed huge improvements by preprocessing with pairwise decomposition and project&subtract compared to the current state-of-the-art solvers on two difficult sets of benchmark.