Constraint-Based Reasoning
On the Complexity of Global Scheduling Constraints under Structural Restrictions
Chu, Geoffrey (University of Melbourne) | Gaspers, Serge (University of New South Wales and NICTA) | Narodytska, Nina (University of New South Wales and NICTA) | Schutt, Andreas (University of Melbourne) | Walsh, Toby (NICTA and University of New South Wales)
We investigate the computational complexity of two global constraints, CUMULATIVE and INTERDISTANCE. These are key constraints in modeling and solving scheduling problems. Enforcing domain consistency on both is NP-hard. However, restricted versions of these constraints are often sufficient in practice. Some examples include scheduling problems with a large number of similar tasks, or tasks sparsely distributed over time. Another example is runway sequencing problems in air-traffic control, where landing periods have a regular pattern. Such cases can be characterized in terms of structural restrictions on the constraints. We identify a number of such structural restrictions and investigate how they impact the computational complexity of propagating these global constraints. In particular, we prove that such restrictions often make propagation tractable.
Detecting and Exploiting Subproblem Tractability
Bessiere, Christian (LIRMM-CNRS) | Carbonnel, Clément (Université de Montpellier) | Hebrard, Emmanuel (Université de Grenoble) | Katsirelos, George (LAAS-CNRS) | Walsh, Toby (Université de Toulouse)
Constraint satisfaction problems may be nearly tractable. For instance, most of the relations in a problem might belong to a tractable language. We introduce a method to take advantage of this fact by computing a backdoor to this tractable language. The method can be applied to many tractable classes for which the membership test is itself tractable. We introduce therefore two polynomial membership testing algorithms, to check if a language is closed under a majority or conservative Mal'tsev polymorphism, respectively. Then we show that computing a minimal backdoor for such classes is fixed parameter tractable (FPT) if the tractable subset of relations is given, and W[2]-complete otherwise. Finally, we report experimental results on the XCSP benchmark set. We identified a few promising problem classes where problems were nearly closed under a majority polymorphism and small backdoors could be computed.
Maintaining Alternative Values in Constraint-Based Configuration
Becker, Caroline (IRIT-CNRS, University of Toulouse) | Fargier, Helene (IRIT-CNRS, University of Toulouse)
Constraint programming techniques are widely used to model and solve interactive decision problems, and especially configuration problems. In this type of application, the configurable product is described by means of a set of constraints bearing on the configuration variables. The user interactively solves the CSP by assigning the variables according to her preferences. The system then has to keep the domains of the other variables consistent with these choices. Since maintaining the global inverse consistency of the domains is not tractable, the domains are instead filtered according to some level of local consistency, e.g. arc-consistency. The present paper aims at offering a more convenient interaction by providing the user with possible alternative values for the already assigned variables, i.e. values that could replace the current ones without leading to a constraint violation. We thus present the new concept of alternative domains in a (possibly) partially assigned CSP. We propose a propagation algorithm that computes all the alternative domains in a single step. Its worst case complexity is comparable to the one of the naive algorithm that would run a full propagation for each variable, but its experimental efficiency is better
Robust Constraint Satisfaction and Local Hidden Variables in Quantum Mechanics
Abramsky, Samson (University of Oxford) | Gottlob, Georg (University of California Santa Cruz and IBM Research - Almaden) | Kolaitis, Phokion
Motivated by considerations in quantum mechanics, we introduce the class of robust constraint satisfaction problems in which the question is whether every partial assignment of a certain length can be extended to a solution, provided the partial assignment does not violate any of the constraints of the given instance. We explore the complexity of specific robust colorability and robust satisfiability problems, and show that they are NP-complete. We then use these results to establish the computational intractability of detecting local hidden-variable models in quantum mechanics.
Efficiently Solving Joint Activity Based Security Games
Shieh, Eric Anyung (University of Southern California) | Jain, Manish (University of Southern California) | Jiang, Albert Xin (University of Southern California) | Tambe, Milind (University of Southern California)
Despite recent successful real-world deployments of Stackelberg Security Games (SSGs), scale-up remains a fundamental challenge in this field. The latest techniques do not scale-up to domains where multiple defenders must coordinate time-dependent joint activities. To address this challenge, this paper presents two branch-and-price algorithms for solving SSGs, SMARTO and SMARTH, with three novel features: (i) a column-generation approach that uses an ordered network of nodes (determined by solving the traveling salesman problem) to generate individual defender strategies; (ii) exploitation of iterative reward shaping of multiple coordinating defender units to generate coordinated strategies; (iii) generation of tighter upper-bounds for pruning by solving security games that only abide by key scheduling constraints. We provide extensive experimental results and formal analyses.
Asymmetric Distributed Constraint Optimization Problems
Grinshpoun, T., Grubshtein, A., Zivan, R., Netzer, A., Meisels, A.
Distributed Constraint Optimization (DCOP) is a powerful framework for representing and solving distributed combinatorial problems, where the variables of the problem are owned by different agents. Many multi-agent problems include constraints that produce different gains (or costs) for the participating agents. Asymmetric gains of constrained agents cannot be naturally represented by the standard DCOP model. The present paper proposes a general framework for Asymmetric DCOPs (ADCOPs). In ADCOPs different agents may have different valuations for constraints that they are involved in. The new framework bridges the gap between multi-agent problems which tend to have asymmetric structure and the standard symmetric DCOP model. The benefits of the proposed model over previous attempts to generalize the DCOP model are discussed and evaluated. Innovative algorithms that apply to the special properties of the proposed ADCOP model are presented in detail. These include complete algorithms that have a substantial advantage in terms of runtime and network load over existing algorithms (for standard DCOPs) which use alternative representations. Moreover, standard incomplete algorithms (i.e., local search algorithms) are inapplicable to the existing DCOP representations of asymmetric constraints and when they are applied to the new ADCOP framework they often fail to converge to a local optimum and yield poor results. The local search algorithms proposed in the present paper converge to high quality solutions. The experimental evidence that is presented reveals that the proposed local search algorithms for ADCOPs achieve high quality solutions while preserving a high level of privacy.
How to minimize the energy consumption in mobile ad-hoc networks
In this work we are interested in the problem of energy management in Mobile Ad-hoc Network (MANET). The solving and optimization of MANET allow assisting the users to efficiently use their devices in order to minimize the batteries power consumption. In this framework, we propose a modelling of the MANET in form of a Constraint Optimization Problem called COMANET. Then, in the objective to minimize the consumption of batteries power, we present an approach based on an adaptation of the Dijkstra's algorithm to the MANET problem called MANED. Finally, we expose some experimental results showing utility of this approach.
Improving MUC extraction thanks to local search
Grégoire, Éric, Lagniez, Jean-Marie, Mazure, Bertrand
ExtractingMUCs(MinimalUnsatisfiableCores)fromanunsatisfiable constraint network is a useful process when causes of unsatisfiability must be understood so that the network can be re-engineered and relaxed to become sat- isfiable. Despite bad worst-case computational complexity results, various MUC- finding approaches that appear tractable for many real-life instances have been proposed. Many of them are based on the successive identification of so-called transition constraints. In this respect, we show how local search can be used to possibly extract additional transition constraints at each main iteration step. The approach is shown to outperform a technique based on a form of model rotation imported from the SAT-related technology and that also exhibits additional transi- tion constraints. Our extensive computational experimentations show that this en- hancement also boosts the performance of state-of-the-art DC(WCORE)-like MUC extractors.
Bandit-Based Search for Constraint Programming
Loth, Manuel (MSR–INRIA Joint Centre) | Sebag, Michèle (Université Paris-Sud) | Hamadi, Youssef (Microsoft Research, Cambridge) | Schulte, Christian (KTH Royal Institute of Technology) | Schoenauer, Marc
Constraint Programming (CP) solvers classically explore the solution space using tree-search based heuristics. Monte-Carlo Tree-Search (MCTS) is a tree-search method aimed at optimal sequential decision making under uncertainty. At the crossroads of CP and MCTS, this paper presents the Bandit Search for Constraint Programming (BASCOP) algorithm, adapting MCTS to the specifics of CP search trees. Formally, MCTS simultaneously estimates the average node reward, and uses it to bias the exploration towards the most promising regions of the tree, borrowing the multi-armed bandit (MAB) decision rule. The two contributions in BASCOP concern i) a specific reward function, estimating the relative failure depth conditionally to a (variable, value) assignment; ii) a new decision rule, hybridizing the MAB framework and the spirit of local neighborhood search. Specifically, BASCOP guides the CP search in the neighborhood of the previous best solution, by exploiting statistical estimates gathered across multiple restarts. BASCOP, using Gecode as the underlying constraint solver, shows significant improvements over the depth-first search baseline on some CP benchmark suites. For hard job-shop scheduling problems, BASCOP matches the results of state-of-the-art scheduling-specific CP approaches. These results demonstrate the potential of BASCOP as a generic yet robust search method for CP.
Tools for Preference Reasoning
Zhu, Ying (University of Kentucky)
The problem of computing similar and dissimilar solutions to a given one has received much attention in constraint satisfaction and answer set programming (ASP). In many practical applications involving product configuration or planning, it is often the case that there are many valid solutions. To help the user see a small but representative sample, one needs algorithms that compute sets of dissimilar solutions. Once the user "zooms" in on one or two that she likes the most, it still makes sense to present several alternatives that are similar to the selected ones so that the user can find one that truly corresponds to her needs.