Constraint-Based Reasoning
Constraint Solving Approaches to the Business-to-Business Meeting Scheduling Problem
Bofill, Miquel, Coll, Jordi, Garcia, Marc, Girรกldez-Cru, Jesรบs, Pesant, Gilles, Suy, Josep, Villaret, Mateu
The Business-to-Business Meeting Scheduling problem consists of scheduling a set of meetings between given pairs of participants to an event, while taking into account participants' availability and accommodation capacity. A crucial aspect of this problem is that breaks in participants' schedules should be avoided as much as possible. It constitutes a challenging combinatorial problem that needs to be solved for many real world brokerage events. In this paper we present a comparative study of Constraint Programming (CP), Mixed-Integer Programming (MIP) and Maximum Satisfiability (MaxSAT) approaches to this problem. The CP approach relies on using global constraints and has been implemented in MiniZinc to be able to compare CP, Lazy Clause Generation and MIP as solving technologies in this setting. We also present a pure MIP encoding. Finally, an alternative viewpoint is considered under MaxSAT, showing best performance when considering some implied constraints. Experiments conducted on real world instances, as well as on crafted ones, show that the MaxSAT approach is the one with the best performance for this problem, exhibiting better solving times, sometimes even orders of magnitude smaller than CP and MIP.
Proactive Dynamic Distributed Constraint Optimization Problems
Hoang, Khoi D. | Fioretto, Ferdinando (Syracuse University) | Hou, Ping (Uber Advanced Technologies Group) | Yeoh, William (Washington University in St. Louis) | Yokoo, Makoto (Kyushu University) | Zivan, Roie (Ben-Gurion University of the Negev)
The Distributed Constraint Optimization Problem (DCOP) formulation is a powerful tool for modeling multi-agent coordination problems. To solve DCOPs in a dynamic environment, Dynamic DCOPs (D-DCOPs) have been proposed to model the inherent dynamism present in many coordination problems. D-DCOPs solve a sequence of static problems by reacting to changes in the environment as the agents observe them. Such reactive approaches ignore knowledge about future changes of the problem. To overcome this limitation, we introduce Proactive Dynamic DCOPs (PD-DCOPs), a novel formalism to model D-DCOPs in the presence of exogenous uncertainty. In contrast to reactive approaches, PD-DCOPs are able to explicitly model possible changes of the problem and take such information into account when solving the dynamically changing problem in a proactive manner. The additional expressivity of this formalism allows it to model a wider variety of distributed optimization problems. Our work presents both theoretical and practical contributions that advance current dynamic DCOP models: (i) We introduce Proactive Dynamic DCOPs (PD-DCOPs), which explicitly model how the DCOP will change over time; (ii) We develop exact and heuristic algorithms to solve PD-DCOPs in a proactive manner; (iii) We provide theoretical results about the complexity of this new class of DCOPs; and (iv) We empirically evaluate both proactive and reactive algorithms to determine the trade-offs between the two classes. The final contribution is important as our results are the first that identify the characteristics of the problems that the two classes of algorithms excel in.
Optimization of process plans using a constraint-based tabu search approach
A computer-aided process planning system should ideally generate and optimize process plans to ensure the application of good manufacturing practices and maintain the consistency of the desired functional specifications of a part during its production processes. Crucial processes, such as selecting machining resources, determining set-up plans and sequencing operations of a part should be considered simultaneously to achieve global optimal solutions. In this paper, these processes are integrated and modelled as a constraint-based optimization problem, and a tabu search-based approach is proposed to solve it effectively. In the optimization model, costs of the utilized machines and cutting tools, machine changes, tool changes, set-ups and departure from good manufacturing practices (penalty function) are the optimization evaluation criteria. Precedence constraints from the geometric and manufacturing interactions between features and their related operations in a part are defined and classified according to their effects on the plan feasibility and processing quality.
Adaptive Stochastic MPC under Unknown Noise Distribution
Stamouli, Charis, Tsiamis, Anastasios, Morari, Manfred, Pappas, George J.
In this paper, we address the stochastic MPC (SMPC) problem for linear systems, subject to chance state constraints and hard input constraints, under unknown noise distribution. First, we reformulate the chance state constraints as deterministic constraints depending only on explicit noise statistics. Based on these reformulated constraints, we design a distributionally robust and robustly stable benchmark SMPC algorithm for the ideal setting of known noise statistics. Then, we employ this benchmark controller to derive a novel robustly stable adaptive SMPC scheme that learns the necessary noise statistics online, while guaranteeing time-uniform satisfaction of the unknown reformulated state constraints with high probability. The latter is achieved through the use of confidence intervals which rely on the empirical noise statistics and are valid uniformly over time. Moreover, control performance is improved over time as more noise samples are gathered and better estimates of the noise statistics are obtained, given the online adaptation of the estimated reformulated constraints. Additionally, in tracking problems with multiple successive targets our approach leads to an online-enlarged domain of attraction compared to robust tube-based MPC. A numerical simulation of a DC-DC converter is used to demonstrate the effectiveness of the developed methodology.
Bayesian optimization with known experimental and design constraints for chemistry applications
Hickman, Riley J., Aldeghi, Matteo, Hรคse, Florian, Aspuru-Guzik, Alรกn
Optimization strategies driven by machine learning, such as Bayesian optimization, are being explored across experimental sciences as an efficient alternative to traditional design of experiment. When combined with automated laboratory hardware and high-performance computing, these strategies enable next-generation platforms for autonomous experimentation. However, the practical application of these approaches is hampered by a lack of flexible software and algorithms tailored to the unique requirements of chemical research. One such aspect is the pervasive presence of constraints in the experimental conditions when optimizing chemical processes or protocols, and in the chemical space that is accessible when designing functional molecules or materials. Although many of these constraints are known a priori, they can be interdependent, non-linear, and result in non-compact optimization domains. In this work, we extend our experiment planning algorithms Phoenics and Gryffin such that they can handle arbitrary known constraints via an intuitive and flexible interface. We benchmark these extended algorithms on continuous and discrete test functions with a diverse set of constraints, demonstrating their flexibility and robustness. In addition, we illustrate their practical utility in two simulated chemical research scenarios: the optimization of the synthesis of o-xylenyl Buckminsterfullerene adducts under constrained flow conditions, and the design of redox active molecules for flow batteries under synthetic accessibility constraints. The tools developed constitute a simple, yet versatile strategy to enable model-based optimization with known experimental constraints, contributing to its applicability as a core component of autonomous platforms for scientific discovery.
Constrained Clustering and Multiple Kernel Learning without Pairwise Constraint Relaxation
Boecking, Benedikt, Jeanselme, Vincent, Dubrawski, Artur
Clustering under pairwise constraints is an important knowledge discovery tool that enables the learning of appropriate kernels or distance metrics to improve clustering performance. These pairwise constraints, which come in the form of must-link and cannot-link pairs, arise naturally in many applications and are intuitive for users to provide. However, the common practice of relaxing discrete constraints to a continuous domain to ease optimization when learning kernels or metrics can harm generalization, as information which only encodes linkage is transformed to informing distances. We introduce a new constrained clustering algorithm that jointly clusters data and learns a kernel in accordance with the available pairwise constraints. To generalize well, our method is designed to maximize constraint satisfaction without relaxing pairwise constraints to a continuous domain where they inform distances. We show that the proposed method outperforms existing approaches on a large number of diverse publicly available datasets, and we discuss how our method can scale to handling large data.
Control Barrier Functions for Systems with Multiple Control Inputs
Xiao, Wei, Cassandras, Christos G., Belta, Calin A., Rus, Daniela
Control Barrier Functions (CBFs) are becoming popular tools in guaranteeing safety for nonlinear systems and constraints, and they can reduce a constrained optimal control problem into a sequence of Quadratic Programs (QPs) for affine control systems. The recently proposed High Order Control Barrier Functions (HOCBFs) work for arbitrary relative degree constraints. One of the challenges in a HOCBF is to address the relative degree problem when a system has multiple control inputs, i.e., the relative degree could be defined with respect to different components of the control vector. This paper proposes two methods for HOCBFs to deal with systems with multiple control inputs: a general integral control method and a method which is simpler but limited to specific classes of physical systems. When control bounds are involved, the feasibility of the above mentioned QPs can also be significantly improved with the proposed methods. We illustrate our approaches on a unicyle model with two control inputs, and compare the two proposed methods to demonstrate their effectiveness and performance.
Local Constraint-Based Causal Discovery under Selection Bias
Versteeg, Philip, Zhang, Cheng, Mooij, Joris M.
We consider the problem of discovering causal relations from independence constraints selection bias in addition to confounding is present. While the seminal FCI algorithm is sound and complete in this setup, no criterion for the causal interpretation of its output under selection bias is presently known. We focus instead on local patterns of independence relations, where we find no sound method for only three variable that can include background knowledge. Y-Structure patterns (Mani et al., 2006; Mooij and Cremers, 2015) are shown to be sound in predicting causal relations from data under selection bias, where cycles may be present. We introduce a finite-sample scoring rule for Y-Structures that is shown to successfully predict causal relations in simulation experiments that include selection mechanisms. On real-world microarray data, we show that a Y-Structure variant performs well across different datasets, potentially circumventing spurious correlations due to selection bias.
Kinematic Control of Redundant Robots with Online Handling of Variable Generalized Hard Constraints
Kazemipour, Amirhossein, Khatib, Maram, Khudir, Khaled Al, Gaz, Claudio, De Luca, Alessandro
We present a generalized version of the Saturation in the Null Space (SNS) algorithm for the task control of redundant robots when hard inequality constraints are simultaneously present both in the joint and in the Cartesian space. These hard bounds should never be violated, are treated equally and in a unified way by the algorithm, and may also be varied, inserted or deleted online. When a joint/Cartesian bound saturates, the robot redundancy is exploited to continue fulfilling the primary task. If no feasible solution exists, an optimal scaling procedure is applied to enforce directional consistency with the original task. Simulation and experimental results on different robotic systems demonstrate the efficiency of the approach. The proposed algorithm can be viewed as a generic platform that is easily applicable to any robotic application in which robots operate in an unstructured environment and online handling of joint and Cartesian constraints is critical.
Polytopic Matrix Factorization: Determinant Maximization Based Criterion and Identifiability
Tatli, Gokcan, Erdogan, Alper T.
We introduce Polytopic Matrix Factorization (PMF) as a novel data decomposition approach. In this new framework, we model input data as unknown linear transformations of some latent vectors drawn from a polytope. In this sense, the article considers a semi-structured data model, in which the input matrix is modeled as the product of a full column rank matrix and a matrix containing samples from a polytope as its column vectors. The choice of polytope reflects the presumed features of the latent components and their mutual relationships. As the factorization criterion, we propose the determinant maximization (Det-Max) for the sample autocorrelation matrix of the latent vectors. We introduce a sufficient condition for identifiability, which requires that the convex hull of the latent vectors contains the maximum volume inscribed ellipsoid of the polytope with a particular tightness constraint. Based on the Det-Max criterion and the proposed identifiability condition, we show that all polytopes that satisfy a particular symmetry restriction qualify for the PMF framework. Having infinitely many polytope choices provides a form of flexibility in characterizing latent vectors. In particular, it is possible to define latent vectors with heterogeneous features, enabling the assignment of attributes such as nonnegativity and sparsity at the subvector level. The article offers examples illustrating the connection between polytope choices and the corresponding feature representations.