Agents
HVAC-Aware Occupancy Scheduling
Lim, BoonPing (NICTA and Australian National University) | Briel, Menkes van den (NICTA and Australian National University) | Thiebaux, Sylvie (NICTA and Australian National University) | Backhaus, Scott (Los Alamos National Laboratory) | Bent, Russell (Los Alamos National Laboratory)
Energy consumption in commercial and educational buildings is impacted by group activities such as meetings, workshops, classes and exams, and can be reduced by scheduling these activities to take place at times and locations that are favorable from an energy standpoint. This paper improves on the effectiveness of energy-aware room-booking and occupancy scheduling approaches, by allowing the scheduling decisions to rely on an explicit model of the building's occupancy-based HVAC control. The core component of our approach is a mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) model which optimally solves the joint occupancy scheduling and occupancy-based HVAC control problem. To scale up to realistic problem sizes, we embed this MILP model into a large neighbourhood search (LNS). We obtain substantial energy reduction in comparison with occupancy-based HVAC control using arbitrary schedules or using schedules obtained by existing heuristic energy-aware scheduling approaches.
Dealing with Ethical Conflicts in Autonomous Agents and Multi-Agent Systems
Belloni, Aline (Ardans SA) | Berger, Alain (Ardans SA) | Boissier, Olivier (ENS Mines Saint-Etienne) | Bonnet, Grégory (Normandie Université) | Bourgne, Gauvain (Pierre and Marie Curie University) | Chardel, Pierre-Antoine (Telecom Management School) | Cotton, Jean-Pierre (Ardans SA) | Evreux, Nicolas (Ardans SA) | Ganascia, Jean-Gabriel (Pierre and Marie Curie University) | Jaillon, Philippe (ENS Mines Saint-Etienne) | Mermet, Bruno (Normandie University) | Picard, Gauthier (ENS Mines Saint-Etienne) | Rever, Bernard (Paris Descartes University) | Simon, Gaële (Normandie University) | Swarte, Thibault de (Telecom Management School) | Tessier, Catherine (Onera) | Vexler, François (Ardans SA) | Voyer, Robert (Telecom Management School) | Zimmermann, Antoine (ENS Mines Saint-Etienne)
Autonomy and agency are a central property in robotic systems, human-machine interfaces, e-business, ambient intelligence and assisted living applications. As the complexity of the situations the autonomous agents may encounter in such contexts is increasing, the decisions those agents make must integrate new issues, e.g. decisions involving contextual ethical considerations. Consequently contributions have proposed recommendations, advice or hard-wired ethical principles for systems of autonomous agents. However, socio-technical systems are more and more open and decentralized, and involve autonomous artificial agents interacting with other agents, human operators or users. For such systems, novel and original methods are needed to address contextual ethical decision-making, as decisions are likely to interfere with one another. This paper aims at presenting the ETHICAA project (Ethics and Autonomous Agents) whose objective is to define what should be an autonomous entity that could manage ethical conflicts. As a first proposal, we present various practical case studies of ethical conflicts and highlight what their main system and decision features are.
Evaluating Assistance to Individuals with Autism in Reasoning about Mental World
Galitsky, Boris (Knowledge Trail Inc) | Shpitsberg, Igor (Rehabilitation Center “Our Sunny World”)
We analyze the results of assistance to individuals with autism in reasoning about mental world. This assistance is provided by a natural language multiagent simulator of mental states, NL_MAMS (Galitsky 2013b). It assists in the tasks which are the hardest for autistic reasoning: operating with mental states and actions. Autistic patients are trained to perform a number of reasoning exercises. We conduct both short term and long term evaluations including the behavior in real world and confirm that the system has a positive effect on their rehabilitation.
Towards Verifiably Ethical Robot Behaviour
Dennis, Louise Abigail (University of Liverpool) | Fisher, Michael (University of Liverpool) | Winfield, Alan (University of the West of England)
Ensuring that autonomous systems work ethically is both complex and difficult. However, the idea of having an additional ‘governor’ that assesses options the system has, and prunes them to select the most ethical choices is well understood. Recent work has produced such a governor consisting of a ‘consequence engine’ that assesses the likely future outcomes of actions then applies a Safety/Ethical logic to select actions. Although this is appealing, it is impossible to be certain that the most ethical options are actually taken. In this paper we extend and apply a well-known agent verification approach to our consequence engine, allowing us to verify the correctness of its ethical decision-making.
Viewing Traffic Signal Control as a Market-Driven Economy
Isukapati, Isaac K. (Carnegie Mellon University) | Smith, Stephen F. (Carnegie Mellon University)
In this paper, economic principles and the paradigm of a game are used to create a signal control strategy. The game structure is not formal (as in game theory), but the idea of a game is used nonetheless. That is, instead of using the standard techniques of minimum greens, maximum greens, and gaps to control the signal indications, an economically based game structure is employed. The intersection’s space is viewed as a scarce commodity whose use is determined through a bidding process. Movement Managers manage the vehicle departures for specific turning movements. Arriving motorists pay the Movement Managers an initial fee, and make voluntary contributions as they perceive necessary to arrange times of entry for them. Movement Managers submit bids for use of the intersection’s space and the highest bidders win. Distributed processing and connected vehicle technology are seen as the mechanisms by which implementation would be feasible. The value in such an idea is that one can study and reach an understanding of the economics that underlie effective traffic control.
Is It Morally Acceptable for a System to Lie to Persuade Me?
Guerini, Marco (Trento RISE) | Pianesi, Fabio (FBK-IRST) | Stock, Oliviero (FBK-IRST)
Given the fast rise of increasingly autonomous artificial agents and robots, a key acceptability criterion will be the possible moral implications of their actions. In particular, intelligent persuasive systems (systems designed to influence humans via communication) constitute a highly sensitive topic because of their intrinsically social nature. Still, ethical studies in this area are rare and tend to focus on the output of the required action. Instead, this work focuses on the persuasive acts themselves (e.g. “is it morally acceptable that a machine lies or appeals to the emotions of a person to persuade her, even if for a good end?”). Exploiting a behavioral approach, based on human assessment of moral dilemmas – i.e. without any prior assumption of underlying ethical theories – this paper reports on a set of experiments. These experiments address the type of persuader (human or machine), the strategies adopted (purely argumentative, appeal to positive emotions, appeal to negative emotions, lie) and the circumstances. Findings display no differences due to the agent, mild acceptability for persuasion and reveal that truth-conditional reasoning (i.e. argument validity) is a significant dimension affecting subjects’ judgment. Some implications for the design of intelligent persuasive systems are discussed.
Adaptive Advice in Automobile Climate Control Systems
Rosenfeld, Ariel (Bar-Ilan University) | Azaria, Amos (Carnegie Mellon University) | Kraus, Sarit ( Bar-Ilan University ) | Goldman, Claudia V. (General Motors Advanced Technical Center) | Tsimhoni, Omer (General Motors Advanced Technical Center)
Reducing an automobile's energy consumption will lower its dependency on fossil fuel and extend the travel range of electric vehicles. Automobile Climate Control Systems (CCS) are known to be heavy energy consumers. To help reduce CCS energy consumption, this paper presents an adaptive automated agent, MDP Agent for Climate control Systems -- MACS, which provides drivers advice as to how to set their CCS. First, we present a model which has 78% accuracy in predicting drivers' reactions to different advice in different situations. Using the prediction model, we designed a Markov Decision Process which solution provided the advising policy for MACS. Through empirical evaluation using an electric car, with 83 human subjects, we show that MACS successfully reduced the energy consumption of the subjects by 33% compared to subjects who were not equipped with MACS. MACS also outperformed the state-of-the-art Social agent for Advice Provision (SAP).
Computational Urban Modeling: From Mainframes to Data Streams
Assuming computational technologies as a dominant factor in forming new scientific methods during the last century, we review the field of computational urban modeling based on the ways different approaches deal with evolving computational and informational capacities. We claim that during the last few years, due to advancements in ubiquitous computing the flow of unstructured data streams have changed the landscape of empirical modeling and simulation. However, there is a conceptual mismatch between the state of the art in urban modeling paradigms and the capacities offered by these urban data streams. We discuss some alternative mathematical methodologies that introduce an abstraction from the traditional urban modeling methodologies.
Human-Robot Systems Facing Ethical Conflicts: A Preliminary Experimental Protocol
Collart, Julien (ONERA) | Gateau, Thibault (Institut Supérieur de l'Aéronautique et de l'Espace - ISAE-SUPAERO) | Fabre, Eve (Institut Supérieur de l'Aéronautique et de l'Espace - ISAE-SUPAEROISAE-SUPAERO) | Tessier, Catherine (ONERA)
This paper focuses on a preliminary experimental protocol that aims at assessing a robot operator’s behavior when the robot is equipped with what appears as moral decision capabilities. The protocol is derived from the trolley dilemma, a well-known decision making paradigm. Indeed the participants, acting as operators of simulated aerial robots via a computer screen, are faced to impersonal moral dilemmas, i.e. decide to crash a damaged robot on one of two inhabited areas, and to non-moral choices, i.e. decide to crash a damaged robot on one of two uninhabited areas. In each situation, the robot has a default crash behavior which is displayed to the participant who will have to decide whether to follow it or not. The participants are equipped with fNIRS and eye-tracking and answer a post-experimental questionnaire. As some of the behavioral and physiological results do not match the hypotheses we had set, we give the features of the further experiments that we are planning.
Toward Ensuring Ethical Behavior from Autonomous Systems: A Case-Supported Principle-Based Paradigm
Anderson, Michael (University of Hartford) | Anderson, Susan Leigh (University of Connecticut)
A paradigm of case-supported principle-based behavior (CPB) is proposed to help ensure ethical behavior of autonomous machines. We argue that ethically significant behavior of autonomous systems should be guided by explicit ethical principles determined through a consensus of ethicists. Such a consensus is likely to emerge in many areas in which autonomous systems are apt to be deployed and for the actions they are liable to undertake, as we are more likely to agree on how machines ought to treat us than on how human beings ought to treat one another. Given such a consensus, particular cases of ethical dilemmas where ethicists agree on the ethically relevant features and the right course of action can be used to help discover principles needed for ethical guidance of the behavior of autonomous systems. Such principles help ensure the ethical behavior of complex and dynamic systems and further serve as a basis for justification of their actions as well as a control abstraction for managing unanticipated behavior. The requirements, methods, implementation, and evaluation components of the CPB paradigm are detailed.