Performance Analysis
Enhancing Large Language Model Reasoning with Reward Models: An Analytical Survey
Liu, Qiyuan, Xu, Hao, Chen, Xuhong, Chen, Wei, Teh, Yee Whye, Miao, Ning
Reward models (RMs) play a critical role in enhancing the reasoning performance of LLMs. For example, they can provide training signals to finetune LLMs during reinforcement learning (RL) and help select the best answer from multiple candidates during inference. In this paper, we provide a systematic introduction to RMs, along with a comprehensive survey of their applications in LLM reasoning. We first review fundamental concepts of RMs, including their architectures, training methodologies, and evaluation techniques. Then, we explore their key applications: (1) guiding generation and selecting optimal outputs during LLM inference, (2) facilitating data synthesis and iterative self-improvement for LLMs, and (3) providing training signals in RL-based finetuning. Finally, we discuss critical open questions regarding the selection, generalization, evaluation, and enhancement of RMs, based on existing research and our own empirical findings. Our analysis aims to provide actionable insights for the effective deployment and advancement of RMs for LLM reasoning.
When Large Language Models are Reliable for Judging Empathic Communication
Kumar, Aakriti, Poungpeth, Nalin, Yang, Diyi, Farrell, Erina, Lambert, Bruce, Groh, Matthew
Large language models (LLMs) excel at generating empathic responses in text-based conversations. But, how reliably do they judge the nuances of empathic communication? We investigate this question by comparing how experts, crowdworkers, and LLMs annotate empathic communication across four evaluative frameworks drawn from psychology, natural language processing, and communications applied to 200 real-world conversations where one speaker shares a personal problem and the other offers support. Drawing on 3,150 expert annotations, 2,844 crowd annotations, and 3,150 LLM annotations, we assess inter-rater reliability between these three annotator groups. We find that expert agreement is high but varies across the frameworks' sub-components depending on their clarity, complexity, and subjectivity. We show that expert agreement offers a more informative benchmark for contextualizing LLM performance than standard classification metrics. Across all four frameworks, LLMs consistently approach this expert level benchmark and exceed the reliability of crowdworkers. These results demonstrate how LLMs, when validated on specific tasks with appropriate benchmarks, can support transparency and oversight in emotionally sensitive applications including their use as conversational companions.
Permissioned LLMs: Enforcing Access Control in Large Language Models
Jayaraman, Bargav, Marathe, Virendra J., Mozaffari, Hamid, Shen, William F., Kenthapadi, Krishnaram
In enterprise settings, organizational data is segregated, siloed and carefully protected by elaborate access control frameworks. These access control structures can completely break down if an LLM fine-tuned on the siloed data serves requests, for downstream tasks, from individuals with disparate access privileges. We propose Permissioned LLMs (PermLLM), a new class of LLMs that superimpose the organizational data access control structures on query responses they generate. We formalize abstractions underpinning the means to determine whether access control enforcement happens correctly over LLM query responses. Our formalism introduces the notion of a relevant response that can be used to prove whether a PermLLM mechanism has been implemented correctly. We also introduce a novel metric, called access advantage, to empirically evaluate the efficacy of a PermLLM mechanism. We introduce three novel PermLLM mechanisms that build on Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning to achieve the desired access control. We furthermore present two instantiations of access advantage--(i) Domain Distinguishability Index (DDI) based on Membership Inference Attacks, and (ii) Utility Gap Index (UGI) based on LLM utility evaluation. We demonstrate the efficacy of our PermLLM mechanisms through extensive experiments on five public datasets (GPQA, RCV1, SimpleQA, WMDP, and PubMedQA), in addition to evaluating the validity of DDI and UGI metrics themselves for quantifying access control in LLMs.
Graph-Reward-SQL: Execution-Free Reinforcement Learning for Text-to-SQL via Graph Matching and Stepwise Reward
Weng, Han, Wu, Puzhen, Cui, Longjie, Zhan, Yi, Liu, Boyi, Song, Yuanfeng, Zeng, Dun, Yang, Yingxiang, Zhang, Qianru, Huang, Dong, Yin, Xiaoming, Sun, Yang, Chen, Xing
Reinforcement learning (RL) has been widely adopted to enhance the performance of large language models (LLMs) on Text-to-SQL tasks. However, existing methods often rely on execution-based or LLM-based Bradley-Terry reward models. The former suffers from high execution latency caused by repeated database calls, whereas the latter imposes substantial GPU memory overhead, both of which significantly hinder the efficiency and scalability of RL pipelines. To this end, we propose a novel reward model framework for RL-based Text-to-SQL named Graph-Reward-SQL, which employs the GMNScore outcome reward model. We leverage SQL graph representations to provide accurate reward signals while significantly reducing time cost and GPU memory usage. Building on this foundation, we further introduce StepRTM, a stepwise reward model that provides intermediate supervision over Common Table Expression (CTE) subqueries. This encourages both functional correctness and readability of SQL. Extensive comparative and ablation experiments on standard benchmarks, including Spider and BIRD, demonstrate that our method consistently outperforms existing reward models.
A Statistical Method for Attack-Agnostic Adversarial Attack Detection with Compressive Sensing Comparison
Wimalasuriya, Chinthana, Tragoudas, Spyros
Adversarial attacks present a significant threat to modern machine learning systems. Y et, existing detection methods often lack the ability to detect unseen attacks or detect different attack types with a high level of accuracy. In this work, we propose a statistical approach that establishes a detection baseline before a neural network's deployment, enabling effective real-time adversarial detection. We generate a metric of adversarial presence by comparing the behavior of a compressed/uncompressed neural network pair. Our method has been tested against state-of-the-art techniques, and it achieves near-perfect detection across a wide range of attack types. Moreover, it significantly reduces false positives, making it both reliable and practical for real-world applications.
Automated Constraint Specification for Job Scheduling by Regulating Generative Model with Domain-Specific Representation
Shi, Yu-Zhe, Xu, Qiao, Li, Yanjia, Liu, Mingchen, Qu, Huamin, Ruan, Lecheng, Wang, Qining
Advanced Planning and Scheduling (APS) systems have become indispensable for modern manufacturing operations, enabling optimized resource allocation and production efficiency in increasingly complex and dynamic environments. While algorithms for solving abstracted scheduling problems have been extensively investigated, the critical prerequisite of specifying manufacturing requirements into formal constraints remains manual and labor-intensive. Although recent advances of generative models, particularly Large Language Models (LLMs), show promise in automating constraint specification from heterogeneous raw manufacturing data, their direct application faces challenges due to natural language ambiguity, non-deterministic outputs, and limited domain-specific knowledge. This paper presents a constraint-centric architecture that regulates LLMs to perform reliable automated constraint specification for production scheduling. The architecture defines a hierarchical structural space organized across three levels, implemented through domain-specific representation to ensure precision and reliability while maintaining flexibility. Furthermore, an automated production scenario adaptation algorithm is designed and deployed to efficiently customize the architecture for specific manufacturing configurations. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed approach successfully balances the generative capabilities of LLMs with the reliability requirements of manufacturing systems, significantly outperforming pure LLM-based approaches in constraint specification tasks.
Adaptive Deception Framework with Behavioral Analysis for Enhanced Cybersecurity Defense
This paper presents CADL (Cognitive-Adaptive Deception Layer), an adaptive deception framework achieving 99.88% detection rate with 0.13% false positive rate on the CICIDS2017 dataset. The framework employs ensemble machine learning (Random Forest, XGBoost, Neural Networks) combined with behavioral profiling to identify and adapt responses to network intrusions. Through a coordinated signal bus architecture, security components share real-time intelligence, enabling collective decision-making. The system profiles attackers based on temporal patterns and deploys customized deception strategies across five escalation levels. Evaluation on 50,000 CICIDS2017 test samples demonstrates that CADL significantly outperforms traditional intrusion detection systems (Snort: 71.2%, Suricata: 68.5%) while maintaining production-ready false positive rates. The framework's behavioral analysis achieves 89% accuracy in classifying attacker profiles. We provide open-source implementation and transparent performance metrics, offering an accessible alternative to commercial deception platforms costing $150-400 per host annually.
Cross-Platform DNA Methylation Classifier for the Eight Molecular Subtypes of Group 3 & 4 Medulloblastoma
Abid, Omer, Rafiee, Gholamreza
Omer Abid, Gholamreza Rafiee * Abstract -- Medulloblastoma is a malignant pediatric brain cancer, and the discovery of molecular subgroups is enabling personalized treatment strategies. In 2019, a consensus identified eight novel subtypes within Groups 3 and 4, each displaying heterogeneous chara cteristics. Classifiers are essential for translating these findings into clinical practice by supporting clinical trials, personalized therapy development and application, and patient monitoring. This study presents a DNA methylation - based, cross - platform machine learning classifier capable of distinguishing these subtypes on both HM450 and EPIC methylation array samples . Across two independent test sets, the model achieved weighted F1 = 0.95 and balanced accuracy = 0.957, consistent across platforms. As the first cross - platform solution, it provides backward compatibility while extending applicability to a newer platform, also enhancing accessibility. It also has the potential to become the first publicly available classifier for these subtypes once deployed through a web application, as planned in the future . Th is work overall takes steps in the direction of advancing precision medicine and improving clinical outcomes for patients within the majority prevalence medulloblastoma subgroups, g roups 3 and 4. Keywords -- Medulloblastoma, Molecular Subgroup Classification, Machine Learning, AI for Health Medulloblastoma is a malignant brain cancer widely known for its prevalence in children. Through extensive treatment strategies based on surgery, chemotherapy and radiation therapy, approximately 75% of the patient are able to survive in the long term [1]. These treatments whi le crucial also come along with negative side effects, effecting patients' li ves [1] [2], especially considering the implications on the growing children. However, with advancement in genomics, molecular subgroups have been discover ed within the disease . T hese subgroups have shown to be heterogenous in clinical, biological and outcomes perspective [3] . These in fact are now considered better definition of disease behaviour than conventional techniques [3] .
Federated Spatiotemporal Graph Learning for Passive Attack Detection in Smart Grids
Agha, Bochra Al, Tajeddine, Razane
Abstract--Smart grids are exposed to passive eavesdropping, where attackers listen silently to communication links. Although no data is actively altered, such reconnaissance can reveal grid topology, consumption patterns, and operational behavior, creating a gateway to more severe targeted attacks. Detecting this threat is difficult because the signals it produces are faint, short-lived, and often disappear when traffic is examined by a single node or along a single timeline. This paper introduces a graph-centric, multimodal detector that fuses physical-layer (Channel State Information (CSI), Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR)) and behavioral (latency, Packet Error Rate (PER), event context) indicators over ego-centric star subgraphs and short temporal windows to detect passive attacks. T o capture stealthy perturbations, a two-stage encoder is introduced: graph convolution aggregates spatial context across ego-centric star subgraphs, while a bidirectional GRU models short-term temporal dependencies. The encoder transforms heterogeneous features into a unified spatio-temporal representation suitable for classification. Training occurs in a federated learning setup under FedProx, improving robustness to heterogeneous local raw data and contributing to the trustworthiness of decentralized training; raw measurements remain on client devices. The model achieves a testing accuracy of 98.32% per-timestep (F1 The results demonstrate that combining spatial and temporal context enables reliable detection of stealthy reconnaissance while maintaining low false-positive rates, making the approach suitable for non-IID federated smart-grid deployments. Smart grids [1] define new energy systems constructed on the notion of bidirectional communication between consumers and utilities. They enable the management of real-time data across distributed nodes. However, this open communication exposes the grid to significant risks of passive attacks, which pose a threat to privacy, trust, and stability [2].
CATMark: A Context-Aware Thresholding Framework for Robust Cross-Task Watermarking in Large Language Models
Zhang, Yu, Liu, Shuliang, Yang, Xu, Hu, Xuming
The expanding capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) have enabled their application in increasingly diverse and sophisticated generation tasks Zhao et al. (2025), from acting as AI agents that produce structured data to solving complex scientific problems and writing functional code Chen et al. (2021); Guo et al. (2024). However, this proliferation of high-quality, machine-generated content poses formidable challenges for authenticity verification Burrus et al. (2024); A yoobi et al. (2024) and the prevention of misuse A yoobi et al. (2023); Dammu et al. (2024). Text watermarking, which embeds imperceptible statistical signals into generated text, has emerged as a promising solution for establishing content provenance Liu et al. (2024); Chen et al. (2023); Y oo et al. (2023). The dominant paradigm involves augmenting the model's output logits; a foundational method, for example, partitions the vocabulary into "green" and "red" lists and adds a positive bias to the logits of green-listed tokens to embed a detectable signature Kirchenbauer et al. (2023). Initial research quickly identified a primary limitation of this approach: its performance degrades significantly in low-entropy contexts, such as code generation, where modifying deterministic tokens can corrupt functional correctness. To address this, subsequent work has focused on entropy-aware adaptations. SWEET Lee et al. (2023) introduced a static entropy threshold, selectively applying the watermark only to high-entropy tokens to preserve low-entropy syntactic structures. Building on this, EWD Lu et al. (2024) refined the detection process by assigning weights to tokens proportional to their entropy, improving sensitivity without a hard threshold. While these methods marked important progress for single-domain tasks, they addressed only part of the problem.