Learning Graphical Models
Unveiling the Statistical Foundations of Chain-of-Thought Prompting Methods
Hu, Xinyang, Zhang, Fengzhuo, Chen, Siyu, Yang, Zhuoran
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting and its variants have gained popularity as effective methods for solving multi-step reasoning problems using pretrained large language models (LLMs). In this work, we analyze CoT prompting from a statistical estimation perspective, providing a comprehensive characterization of its sample complexity. To this end, we introduce a multi-step latent variable model that encapsulates the reasoning process, where the latent variable encodes the task information. Under this framework, we demonstrate that when the pretraining dataset is sufficiently large, the estimator formed by CoT prompting is equivalent to a Bayesian estimator. This estimator effectively solves the multi-step reasoning problem by aggregating a posterior distribution inferred from the demonstration examples in the prompt. Moreover, we prove that the statistical error of the CoT estimator can be decomposed into two main components: (i) a prompting error, which arises from inferring the true task using CoT prompts, and (ii) the statistical error of the pretrained LLM. We establish that, under appropriate assumptions, the prompting error decays exponentially to zero as the number of demonstrations increases. Additionally, we explicitly characterize the approximation and generalization errors of the pretrained LLM. Notably, we construct a transformer model that approximates the target distribution of the multi-step reasoning problem with an error that decreases exponentially in the number of transformer blocks. Our analysis extends to other variants of CoT, including Self-Consistent CoT, Tree-of-Thought, and Selection-Inference, offering a broad perspective on the efficacy of these methods. We also provide numerical experiments to validate the theoretical findings.
Negative Binomial Matrix Completion
Lu, Yu, Bui, Kevin, Marcia, Roummel F.
Matrix completion focuses on recovering missing or incomplete information in matrices. This problem arises in various applications, including image processing and network analysis. Previous research proposed Poisson matrix completion for count data with noise that follows a Poisson distribution, which assumes that the mean and variance are equal. Since overdispersed count data, whose variance is greater than the mean, is more likely to occur in realistic settings, we assume that the noise follows the negative binomial (NB) distribution, which can be more general than the Poisson distribution. In this paper, we introduce NB matrix completion by proposing a nuclear-norm regularized model that can be solved by proximal gradient descent. In our experiments, we demonstrate that the NB model outperforms Poisson matrix completion in various noise and missing data settings on real data.
Harnessing the Intrinsic Knowledge of Pretrained Language Models for Challenging Text Classification Settings
Text classification, a classic task in natural language processing (NLP), involves assigning predefined categories to textual data and is crucial for applications ranging from sentiment analysis to spam detection. This thesis advances text classification by harnessing the intrinsic knowledge of Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) to address three challenging scenarios: distractor selection for multiple-choice cloze questions, improving robustness for prompt-based zero-shot text classification, and demonstration selection for retrieval-based in-context learning. Firstly, we focus on selecting distractors for multiple-choice cloze questions, ensuring that they are misleading yet incorrect. We assess the relationship between human experts' annotations (accept/reject) and various features, including context-free features (e.g., word frequency) and context-sensitive features (e.g., conditional probabilities of fillin-the-blank words). We utilize pretrained embeddings and follow annotation instructions for context-free feature design, and we find that using contextualized word representations from PLMs as features drastically improves performance over traditional feature-based models, even rivaling human performance (Chapter 3).
Generalized Naive Bayes
Kovács, Edith Alice, Ország, Anna, Pfeifer, Dániel, Benczúr, András
In this paper we introduce the so-called Generalized Naive Bayes structure as an extension of the Naive Bayes structure. We give a new greedy algorithm that finds a good fitting Generalized Naive Bayes (GNB) probability distribution. We prove that this fits the data at least as well as the probability distribution determined by the classical Naive Bayes (NB). Then, under a not very restrictive condition, we give a second algorithm for which we can prove that it finds the optimal GNB probability distribution, i.e. best fitting structure in the sense of KL divergence. Both algorithms are constructed to maximize the information content and aim to minimize redundancy. Based on these algorithms, new methods for feature selection are introduced. We discuss the similarities and differences to other related algorithms in terms of structure, methodology, and complexity. Experimental results show, that the algorithms introduced outperform the related algorithms in many cases.
Pixels to Prose: Understanding the art of Image Captioning
Singh, Hrishikesh, Sharma, Aarti, Pant, Millie
In the era of evolving artificial intelligence, machines are increasingly emulating human-like capabilities, including visual perception and linguistic expression. Image captioning stands at the intersection of these domains, enabling machines to interpret visual content and generate descriptive text. This paper provides a thorough review of image captioning techniques, catering to individuals entering the field of machine learning who seek a comprehensive understanding of available options, from foundational methods to state-of-the-art approaches. Beginning with an exploration of primitive architectures, the review traces the evolution of image captioning models to the latest cutting-edge solutions. By dissecting the components of these architectures, readers gain insights into the underlying mechanisms and can select suitable approaches tailored to specific problem requirements without duplicating efforts. The paper also delves into the application of image captioning in the medical domain, illuminating its significance in various real-world scenarios. Furthermore, the review offers guidance on evaluating the performance of image captioning systems, highlighting key metrics for assessment. By synthesizing theoretical concepts with practical application, this paper equips readers with the knowledge needed to navigate the complex landscape of image captioning and harness its potential for diverse applications in machine learning and beyond.
Improving Thompson Sampling via Information Relaxation for Budgeted Multi-armed Bandits
We consider a Bayesian budgeted multi-armed bandit problem, in which each arm consumes a different amount of resources when selected and there is a budget constraint on the total amount of resources that can be used. Budgeted Thompson Sampling (BTS) offers a very effective heuristic to this problem, but its arm-selection rule does not take into account the remaining budget information. We adopt \textit{Information Relaxation Sampling} framework that generalizes Thompson Sampling for classical $K$-armed bandit problems, and propose a series of algorithms that are randomized like BTS but more carefully optimize their decisions with respect to the budget constraint. In a one-to-one correspondence with these algorithms, a series of performance benchmarks that improve the conventional benchmark are also suggested. Our theoretical analysis and simulation results show that our algorithms (and our benchmarks) make incremental improvements over BTS (respectively, the conventional benchmark) across various settings including a real-world example.
A Kernel-Based Conditional Two-Sample Test Using Nearest Neighbors (with Applications to Calibration, Regression Curves, and Simulation-Based Inference)
Chatterjee, Anirban, Niu, Ziang, Bhattacharya, Bhaswar B.
In this paper we introduce a kernel-based measure for detecting differences between two conditional distributions. Using the `kernel trick' and nearest-neighbor graphs, we propose a consistent estimate of this measure which can be computed in nearly linear time (for a fixed number of nearest neighbors). Moreover, when the two conditional distributions are the same, the estimate has a Gaussian limit and its asymptotic variance has a simple form that can be easily estimated from the data. The resulting test attains precise asymptotic level and is universally consistent for detecting differences between two conditional distributions. We also provide a resampling based test using our estimate that applies to the conditional goodness-of-fit problem, which controls Type I error in finite samples and is asymptotically consistent with only a finite number of resamples. A method to de-randomize the resampling test is also presented. The proposed methods can be readily applied to a broad range of problems, ranging from classical nonparametric statistics to modern machine learning. Specifically, we explore three applications: testing model calibration, regression curve evaluation, and validation of emulator models in simulation-based inference. We illustrate the superior performance of our method for these tasks, both in simulations as well as on real data. In particular, we apply our method to (1) assess the calibration of neural network models trained on the CIFAR-10 dataset, (2) compare regression functions for wind power generation across two different turbines, and (3) validate emulator models on benchmark examples with intractable posteriors and for generating synthetic `redshift' associated with galaxy images.
How transformers learn structured data: insights from hierarchical filtering
Garnier-Brun, Jerome, Mézard, Marc, Moscato, Emanuele, Saglietti, Luca
We introduce a hierarchical filtering procedure for generative models of sequences on trees, enabling control over the range of positional correlations in the data. Leveraging this controlled setting, we provide evidence that vanilla encoder-only transformer architectures can implement the optimal Belief Propagation algorithm on both root classification and masked language modeling tasks. Correlations at larger distances corresponding to increasing layers of the hierarchy are sequentially included as the network is trained. We analyze how the transformer layers succeed by focusing on attention maps from models trained with varying degrees of filtering. These attention maps show clear evidence for iterative hierarchical reconstruction of correlations, and we can relate these observations to a plausible implementation of the exact inference algorithm for the network sizes considered. Transformer-based large language models have revolutionized natural language processing, and have notably demonstrated their capacity to perfectly assimilate the grammatical rules of the languages they are trained on. While this evidence shows that transformers can handle and exploit the subtle long-range correlations that emerge in natural language, their inner workings remain largely unclear. Due to the complexity of the standard multi-layer transformer architecture (Vaswani et al., 2017), understanding what strategy is precisely implemented via the attention mechanism to solve a given problem has been limited so far to very simple tasks (Weiss et al., 2021; Zhong et al., 2024; Behrens et al., 2024). Nonetheless, significant results have been obtained by studying transformers on simplified models of language known as Context-Free Grammars (CFGs).
Measuring text summarization factuality using atomic facts entailment metrics in the context of retrieval augmented generation
The use of large language models (LLMs) has significantly increased since the introduction of ChatGPT in 2022, demonstrating their value across various applications. However, a major challenge for enterprise and commercial adoption of LLMs is their tendency to generate inaccurate information, a phenomenon known as "hallucination." This project proposes a method for estimating the factuality of a summary generated by LLMs when compared to a source text. Our approach utilizes Naive Bayes classification to assess the accuracy of the content produced.
Quotient Normalized Maximum Likelihood Criterion for Learning Bayesian Network Structures
Silander, Tomi, Leppä-aho, Janne, Jääsaari, Elias, Roos, Teemu
We introduce an information theoretic criterion for Bayesian network structure learning which we call quotient normalized maximum likelihood (qNML). In contrast to the closely related factorized normalized maximum likelihood criterion, qNML satisfies the property of score equivalence. It is also decomposable and completely free of adjustable hyperparameters. For practical computations, we identify a remarkably accurate approximation proposed earlier by Szpankowski and Weinberger. Experiments on both simulated and real data demonstrate that the new criterion leads to parsimonious models with good predictive accuracy.