Undirected Networks
Model Complexity, Goodness of Fit and Diminishing Returns
Cadez, Igor V., Smyth, Padhraic
Such learning tasks can typically be characterized by the existence of a model and a loss function. A fitted model of complexity k is a function of the data points D and depends on a specific set of fitted parameters B. The loss function (goodnessof-fit) is a functional of the model and maps each specific model to a scalar used to evaluate the model, e.g., likelihood for density estimation or sum-of-squares for regression. Figure 1 illustrates a typical empirical curve for loss function versus complexity, for mixtures of Markov models fitted to a large data set of 900,000 sequences. The complexity k is the number of Markov models being used in the mixture (see Cadez et al. (2000) for further details on the model and the data set). The empirical curve has a distinctly concave appearance, with large relative gains in fit for low complexity models and much more modest relative gains for high complexity models.
Reinforcement Learning with Function Approximation Converges to a Region
Many algorithms for approximate reinforcement learning are not known to converge. In fact, there are counterexamples showing that the adjustable weights in some algorithms may oscillate within a region rather than converging to a point. This paper shows that, for two popular algorithms, such oscillation is the worst that can happen: the weights cannot diverge, but instead must converge to a bounded region. The algorithms are SARSA(O) and V(O); the latter algorithm was used in the well-known TD-Gammon program. 1 Introduction Although there are convergent online algorithms (such as TD()') [1]) for learning the parameters of a linear approximation to the value function of a Markov process, no way is known to extend these convergence proofs to the task of online approximation ofeither the state-value (V*) or the action-value (Q*) function of a general Markov decision process. In fact, there are known counterexamples to many proposed algorithms.For example, fitted value iteration can diverge even for Markov processes [2]; Q-Iearning with linear function approximators can diverge, even when the states are updated according to a fixed update policy [3]; and SARSA(O) can oscillate between multiple policies with different value functions [4].
The Use of Classifiers in Sequential Inference
We study the problem of combining the outcomes of several different classifiers in a way that provides a coherent inference that satisfies some constraints. In particular, we develop two general approaches for an important subproblem-identifying phrase structure. The first is a Markovian approach that extends standard HMMs to allow the use of a rich observation structureand of general classifiers to model state-observation dependencies. The second is an extension of constraint satisfaction formalisms. Wedevelop efficient combination algorithms under both models and study them experimentally in the context of shallow parsing.
Model Complexity, Goodness of Fit and Diminishing Returns
Cadez, Igor V., Smyth, Padhraic
Igor V. Cadez Information and Computer Science University of California Irvine, CA 92697-3425, U.S.A. PadhraicSmyth Information and Computer Science University of California Irvine, CA 92697-3425, U.S.A. Abstract We investigate a general characteristic of the tradeoff in learning problems between goodness-of-fit and model complexity. Specifically wecharacterize a general class of learning problems where the goodness-of-fit function can be shown to be convex within firstorder asa function of model complexity. This general property of "diminishing returns" is illustrated on a number of real data sets and learning problems, including finite mixture modeling and multivariate linear regression. 1 Introduction, Motivation, and Related Work Assume we have a data set D Such learning tasks can typically be characterized by the existence of a model and a loss function. A fitted model of complexity k is a function of the data points D and depends on a specific set of fitted parameters B. The loss function (goodnessof-fit) isa functional of the model and maps each specific model to a scalar used to evaluate the model, e.g., likelihood for density estimation or sum-of-squares for regression. Figure 1 illustrates a typical empirical curve for loss function versus complexity, for mixtures of Markov models fitted to a large data set of 900,000 sequences.
New Approaches Towards Robust and Adaptive Speech Recognition
Bourlard, Hervรฉ, Bengio, Samy, Weber, Katrin
In this paper, we discuss some new research directions in automatic speech recognition (ASR), and which somewhat deviate from the usual approaches. More specifically, we will motivate and briefly describe new approaches based on multi-stream and multi/band ASR. These approaches extend the standard hidden Markov model (HMM) based approach by assuming that the different (frequency) channels representing the speech signal are processed by different (independent) "experts", each expert focusing on a different characteristic ofthe signal, and that the different stream likelihoods (or posteriors) are combined at some (temporal) stage to yield a global recognition output. As a further extension to multi-stream ASR, we will finally introduce a new approach, referred to as HMM2, where the HMM emission probabilities are estimated via state specific featurebased HMMs responsible for merging the stream information andmodeling their possible correlation.
Using Free Energies to Represent Q-values in a Multiagent Reinforcement Learning Task
Sallans, Brian, Hinton, Geoffrey E.
The problem of reinforcement learning in large factored Markov decision processes is explored. The Q-value of a state-action pair is approximated by the free energy of a product of experts network. Network parameters are learned online using a modified SARSA algorithm which minimizes the inconsistency of the Q-values of consecutive state-action pairs. Actions arechosen based on the current value estimates by fixing the current state and sampling actions from the network using Gibbs sampling. The algorithm is tested on a cooperative multi-agent task. The product of experts model is found to perform comparably to table-based Q-Iearning for small instances of the task, and continues to perform well when the problem becomes too large for a table-based representation.
Kernel-Based Reinforcement Learning in Average-Cost Problems: An Application to Optimal Portfolio Choice
Ormoneit, Dirk, Glynn, Peter W.
Many approaches to reinforcement learning combine neural networks orother parametric function approximators with a form of temporal-difference learning to estimate the value function of a Markov Decision Process. A significant disadvantage of those procedures isthat the resulting learning algorithms are frequently unstable. In this work, we present a new, kernel-based approach to reinforcement learning which overcomes this difficulty and provably converges to a unique solution. By contrast to existing algorithms, our method can also be shown to be consistent in the sense that its costs converge to the optimal costs asymptotically. Our focus is on learning in an average-cost framework and on a practical application tothe optimal portfolio choice problem. 1 Introduction Temporal-difference (TD) learning has been applied successfully to many real-world applications that can be formulated as discrete state Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) with unknown transition probabilities.
Interactive Parts Model: An Application to Recognition of On-line Cursive Script
Neskovic, Predrag, Davis, Philip C., Cooper, Leon N.
In this work, we introduce an Interactive Parts (IP) model as an alternative to Hidden Markov Models (HMMs). We tested both models on a database of online cursive script. We show that implementations ofHMMs and the IP model, in which all letters are assumed to have the same average width, give comparable results. However, in contrast to HMMs, the IP model can handle duration modeling without an increase in computational complexity. 1 Introduction Hidden Markov models [9] have been a dominant paradigm in speech and handwriting recognitionover the past several decades. The success of HMMs is primarily due to their ability to model the statistical and sequential nature of speech and handwriting data.
Rate-coded Restricted Boltzmann Machines for Face Recognition
Teh, Yee Whye, Hinton, Geoffrey E.
We describe a neurally-inspired, unsupervised learning algorithm that builds a nonlinear generative model for pairs of face images from the same individual. Individuals are then recognized by finding the highest relative probability pair among all pairs that consist of a test image and an image whose identity is known. Our method compares favorably with other methods in the literature. The generative model consists of a single layer of rate-coded, nonlinear feature detectors and it has the property that, given a data vector, the true posterior probability distribution over the feature detector activities can be inferred rapidly without iteration or approximation. The weights of the feature detectors are learned by comparing thecorrelations of pixel intensities and feature activations in two phases: When the network is observing real data and when it is observing reconstructions of real data generated from the feature activations.