Decision Tree Learning
Making Sense of Random Forest Probabilities: a Kernel Perspective
Olson, Matthew A., Wyner, Abraham J.
A random forest is a popular tool for estimating probabilities in machine learning classification tasks. However, the means by which this is accomplished is unprincipled: one simply counts the fraction of trees in a forest that vote for a certain class. In this paper, we forge a connection between random forests and kernel regression. This places random forest probability estimation on more sound statistical footing. As part of our investigation, we develop a model for the proximity kernel and relate it to the geometry and sparsity of the estimation problem. We also provide intuition and recommendations for tuning a random forest to improve its probability estimates.
Machine Learning in Official Statistics
Beck, Martin, Dumpert, Florian, Feuerhake, Joerg
On 10 October 2017, the development of a Digital Agenda of the Federal Statistical Office of Germany (Destatis) has started (Statistisches Bundesamt 2018). One of many topics that were intensively discussed was Machine Learning. In a meeting at 13-15 November 2017, the office and department heads of Destatis evaluated and prioritised 59 measures of the Digital Agenda according to their benefits and costs. A "Proof of Concept Machine Learning" was given high priority and classified as one of four lighthouse projects of the Digital Agenda. The content specification was "Proof of Concept Machine Learning - Set up Proof of Concept for Machine Learning, e.g. in business statistics, to perform automatic categorization and improve analysis potential". The deadline for completion of the project was set for mid-2018.
Can we learn where people go?
Gรถdel, Marion, Kรถster, Gerta, Lehmberg, Daniel, Gruber, Manfred, Kneidl, Angelika, Sesser, Florian
In most agent-based simulators, pedestrians navigate from origins to destinations. Consequently, destinations are essential input parameters to the simulation. While many other relevant parameters as positions, speeds and densities can be obtained from sensors, like cameras, destinations cannot be observed directly. Our research question is: Can we obtain this information from video data using machine learning methods? We use density heatmaps, which indicate the pedestrian density within a given camera cutout, as input to predict the destination distributions. For our proof of concept, we train a Random Forest predictor on an exemplary data set generated with the VADERE microscopic simulator. The scenario is a crossroad where pedestrians can head left, straight or right. In addition, we gain first insights on suitable placement of the camera. The results motivate an in-depth analysis of the methodology.
MLIC: A MaxSAT-Based framework for learning interpretable classification rules
Malioutov, Dmitry, Meel, Kuldeep S.
The wide adoption of machine learning approaches in the industry, government, medicine and science has renewed the interest in interpretable machine learning: many decisions are too important to be delegated to black-box techniques such as deep neural networks or kernel SVMs. Historically, problems of learning interpretable classifiers, including classification rules or decision trees, have been approached by greedy heuristic methods as essentially all the exact optimization formulations are NP-hard. Our primary contribution is a MaxSAT-based framework, called MLIC, which allows principled search for interpretable classification rules expressible in propositional logic. Our approach benefits from the revolutionary advances in the constraint satisfaction community to solve large-scale instances of such problems. In experimental evaluations over a collection of benchmarks arising from practical scenarios, we demonstrate its effectiveness: we show that the formulation can solve large classification problems with tens or hundreds of thousands of examples and thousands of features, and to provide a tunable balance of accuracy vs. interpretability. Furthermore, we show that in many problems interpretability can be obtained at only a minor cost in accuracy. The primary objective of the paper is to show that recent advances in the MaxSAT literature make it realistic to find optimal (or very high quality near-optimal) solutions to large-scale classification problems. The key goal of the paper is to excite researchers in both interpretable classification and in the CP community to take it further and propose richer formulations, and to develop bespoke solvers attuned to the problem of interpretable ML.
An empirical study on hyperparameter tuning of decision trees
Mantovani, Rafael Gomes, Horvรกth, Tomรกลก, Cerri, Ricardo, Junior, Sylvio Barbon, Vanschoren, Joaquin, de Carvalho, Andrรฉ Carlos Ponce de Leon Ferreira
Machine learning algorithms often contain many hyperparameters whose values affect the predictive performance of the induced models in intricate ways. Due to the high number of possibilities for these hyperparameter configurations, and their complex interactions, it is common to use optimization techniques to find settings that lead to high predictive accuracy. However, we lack insight into how to efficiently explore this vast space of configurations: which are the best optimization techniques, how should we use them, and how significant is their effect on predictive or runtime performance? This paper provides a comprehensive approach for investigating the effects of hyperparameter tuning on three Decision Tree induction algorithms, CART, C4.5 and CTree. These algorithms were selected because they are based on similar principles, have presented a high predictive performance in several previous works and induce interpretable classification models. Additionally, they contain many interacting hyperparameters to be adjusted. Experiments were carried out with different tuning strategies to induce models and evaluate the relevance of hyperparameters using 94 classification datasets from OpenML. Experimental results indicate that hyperparameter tuning provides statistically significant improvements for C4.5 and CTree in only one-third of the datasets, and in most of the datasets for CART. Different tree algorithms may present different tuning scenarios, but in general, the tuning techniques required relatively few iterations to find accurate solutions. Furthermore, the best technique for all the algorithms was the Irace. Finally, we find that tuning a specific small subset of hyperparameters contributes most of the achievable optimal predictive performance.
Please Stop Explaining Black Box Models for High Stakes Decisions
Black box machine learning models are currently being used for high stakes decision-making throughout society, causing problems throughout healthcare, criminal justice, and in other domains. People have hoped that creating methods for explaining these black box models will alleviate some of these problems, but trying to explain black box models, rather than creating models that are interpretable in the first place, is likely to perpetuate bad practices and can potentially cause catastrophic harm to society. There is a way forward - it is to design models that are inherently interpretable.
Automatic Induction of Neural Network Decision Tree Algorithms
This work presents an approach to automatically induction for non-greedy decision trees constructed from neural network architecture. This construction can be used to transfer weights when growing or pruning a decision tree, allowing non-greedy decision tree algorithms to automatically learn and adapt to the ideal architecture. In this work, we examine the underpinning ideas within ensemble modelling and Bayesian model averaging which allow our neural network to asymptotically approach the ideal architecture through weights transfer. Experimental results demonstrate that this approach improves models over fixed set of hyperparameters for decision tree models and decision forest models.
Classification when Learning is not Feasible
Consider classification problems, where attributes do not give any information about the class label. I do not know what kind of behavior to expect when running a classification algorithm in this setting (let's assume ID3 decision trees for simplicity). The decision tree constructed should be some kind of "empty" model, because it's even less than a decision stump (i.e. In practice, the model is likely to fit the noise, and find some kind of pattern that does not exist. The algorithm could still manage to come up with some decision tree on data that is in actual fact random.
Intersectionality: Multiple Group Fairness in Expectation Constraints
Fitzsimons, Jack, Osborne, Michael, Roberts, Stephen
Group fairness is an important concern for machine learning researchers, developers, and regulators. However, the strictness to which models must be constrained to be considered fair is still under debate. The focus of this work is on constraining the expected outcome of subpopulations in kernel regression and, in particular, decision tree regression, with application to random forests, boosted trees and other ensemble models. While individual constraints were previously addressed, this work addresses concerns about incorporating multiple constraints simultaneously. The proposed solution does not affect the order of computational or memory complexity of the decision trees and is easily integrated into models post training.