Problem Solving
When to Trust the Cheap Check: Weak and Strong Verification for Reasoning
Kiyani, Shayan, Noorani, Sima, Pappas, George, Hassani, Hamed
Reasoning with LLMs increasingly unfolds inside a broader verification loop. Internally, systems use cheap checks, such as self-consistency or proxy rewards, which we call weak verification. Externally, users inspect outputs and steer the model through feedback until results are trustworthy, which we call strong verification. These signals differ sharply in cost and reliability: strong verification can establish trust but is resource-intensive, while weak verification is fast and scalable but noisy and imperfect. We formalize this tension through weak--strong verification policies, which decide when to accept or reject based on weak verification and when to defer to strong verification. We introduce metrics capturing incorrect acceptance, incorrect rejection, and strong-verification frequency. Over population, we show that optimal policies admit a two-threshold structure and that calibration and sharpness govern the value of weak verifiers. Building on this, we develop an online algorithm that provably controls acceptance and rejection errors without assumptions on the query stream, the language model, or the weak verifier.
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Natural Language > Large Language Model (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Cognitive Science > Problem Solving (0.93)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Neural Networks > Deep Learning (0.68)
- Asia > China > Beijing > Beijing (0.04)
- North America > United States (0.04)
- Asia > China > Shanghai > Shanghai (0.04)
- (3 more...)
- Health & Medicine (0.68)
- Education > Educational Setting (0.46)
- Energy > Renewable (0.45)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning > Search (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning > Planning & Scheduling (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Natural Language > Large Language Model (1.00)
- (2 more...)
- North America > United States > Virginia (0.04)
- Asia > China > Guangdong Province > Shenzhen (0.04)
- Europe > France (0.04)
- (3 more...)
- Research Report > New Finding (1.00)
- Research Report > Experimental Study (0.93)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Natural Language > Large Language Model (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Neural Networks > Deep Learning (1.00)
- (2 more...)
- North America > United States > Minnesota > Hennepin County > Minneapolis (0.14)
- Europe > United Kingdom > England (0.04)
- North America > Canada > Ontario > Toronto (0.04)
- (9 more...)
- Research Report > Experimental Study (0.93)
- Research Report > New Finding (0.67)
- Leisure & Entertainment (1.00)
- Media > Film (0.93)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Natural Language > Large Language Model (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Cognitive Science > Problem Solving (0.69)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Neural Networks > Deep Learning (0.32)
- North America > United States > Minnesota > Hennepin County > Minneapolis (0.14)
- Europe > Ukraine > Kyiv Oblast > Kyiv (0.05)
- Asia > Middle East > Syria (0.04)
- (18 more...)
- Government (1.00)
- Law (0.93)
- Leisure & Entertainment > Sports > Basketball (0.67)
- Law Enforcement & Public Safety (0.67)
- North America > United States > California (0.14)
- North America > Canada > Ontario > Toronto (0.04)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Natural Language > Large Language Model (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Cognitive Science > Problem Solving (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Neural Networks > Deep Learning (0.97)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Cognitive Science > Problem Solving (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Natural Language > Large Language Model (0.85)
- Europe > France (0.04)
- North America > United States > Massachusetts > Hampshire County > Amherst (0.04)
- Asia > Myanmar > Tanintharyi Region > Dawei (0.04)
- (5 more...)
- Workflow (1.00)
- Research Report > New Finding (1.00)
- Research Report > Experimental Study (0.92)
- Leisure & Entertainment > Games (1.00)
- Health & Medicine > Therapeutic Area (0.67)
- Information Technology > Security & Privacy (0.67)
- North America > United States > Minnesota > Hennepin County > Minneapolis (0.14)
- Europe > Austria > Vienna (0.14)
- North America > United States > Louisiana > Orleans Parish > New Orleans (0.04)
- (13 more...)
- Research Report > New Finding (1.00)
- Research Report > Experimental Study (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Representation & Reasoning (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Natural Language > Large Language Model (1.00)
- Information Technology > Artificial Intelligence > Machine Learning > Neural Networks > Deep Learning (1.00)
- (2 more...)