Law
The Utility of Text: The Case of Amicus Briefs and the Supreme Court
Sim, Yanchuan, Routledge, Bryan, Smith, Noah A.
We explore the idea that authoring a piece of text is an act of maximizing one's expected utility. To make this idea concrete, we consider the societally important decisions of the Supreme Court of the United States. Extensive past work in quantitative political science provides a framework for empirically modeling the decisions of justices and how they relate to text. We incorporate into such a model texts authored by amici curiae ("friends of the court" separate from the litigants) who seek to weigh in on the decision, then explicitly model their goals in a random utility model. We demonstrate the benefits of this approach in improved vote prediction and the ability to perform counterfactual analysis.
Conscious Machines? Trajectories, Possibilities, and Neuroethical Considerations
Giordano, James (Georgetown University Medical Center)
Research in neurally-based machine (i.e. computational) systems is expanding. โReverse-engineeredโ models of brain-like structures are viable candidates for developing increasing complexification (via generatively encoded โintelligenceโ) that could instantiate some form of consciousness โ albeit not identical to human consciousness. This essay posits how such trajectories could lead to the iterative development of โmachine sentienceโ and addresses issues of what โmachine consciousnessโ might mean for: 1) the ways that humans regard such machine entities as โbeingsโ and/or โpersonsโ, and 2) philosophical, ethical and socio-legal positions which might need to be adapted to guide and govern human treatment of, and interactions with such entities. Herein, I argue that neuroethics contributes crucial insights and viable tools to any meaningful approach to this topic (in synergy with extant discourse in โrobo-ethicsโ). As the fields of neuro- and cognitive science, and computational engineering become increasingly convergent, so too must the philosophical and ethical approaches that can โ and should โ be employed to direct what convergent science may create. The speed and breadth of such technological development are such that neuroethical address and engagement of these issues and questions must be equivalently paced and iterative, so as to retain preparatory value.
Identifying Relevant Text Fragments to Help Crowdsource Privacy Policy Annotations
Ramanath, Rohan (Carnegie Mellon University) | Schaub, Florian (Carnegie Mellon University) | Wilson, Shomir (Carnegie Mellon University) | Liu, Fei (Carnegie Mellon University) | Sadeh, Norman (Carnegie Mellon University) | Smith, Noah A (Carnegie Mellon University)
In today's age of big data, websites are collecting an increasingly wide variety of information about their users. The texts of websites' privacy policies, which serve as legal agreements between service providers and users, are often long and difficult to understand. Automated analysis of those texts has the potential to help users better understand the implications of agreeing to such policies. In this work, we present a technique that combines machine learning and crowdsourcing to semi-automatically extract key aspects of website privacy policies that is scalable, fast, and cost-effective.
Crowdsourcing the Extraction of Data Practices from Privacy Policies
Schaub, Florian (Carnegie Mellon University) | Breaux, Travis D (Carnegie Mellon University) | Sadeh, Norman (Carnegie Mellon University)
Website and mobile application privacy policies are intended to describe the systemโs data practices. However, they are often written in non-standard formats and contain ambiguities that make it difficult for users to read and comprehend these documents. We propose a crowdsourcing approach to extract data practices from privacy policies to provide more concise and useable privacy notices to users and support the analysis of stated data practices. To that end, we designed a hierarchical task workflow for crowdsourcing the extraction of data practices from privacy policies. We discuss our workflow design and report preliminary results.
Crowd-Training Machine Learning Systems for Human Rights Abuse Documentation
Aronson, Jay D. (Carnegie Mellon University)
In this talk, I will describe efforts being undertaken in a collaboration between human rights advocates and Social media and mobile phones with good cameras and computer scientists at Carnegie Mellon University to Internet access are dramatically changing the nature of develop tools, methods and algorithms that will make it human rights documentation, reporting and advocacy. Key to this process, and like YouTube, Live Leak, Vimeo, and Facebook every apropos of this session, is the development of mechanisms week. In Syria, more than 650,000 videos have been to enable "the crowd" (i.e., those individuals around the uploaded to social media sites since the conflict started world who care about human rights and have relevant three years ago. This trove of interest dies down or moves on to new issues or places. In presenting this relevant in the long-term, what is irrelevant to the project, I hope to get feedback from other participants in situation or repetitive, and what is patently false or the workshop on how to achieve this goal, particularly by misleading.
Column
The use of artificial intelligence (AI) in life sciences, or "Life Tech", has increased at a rapid pace. According to World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), there has been "a shift from theoretical research to the use of AI technologies in commercial products and services," as reflected in the change in ratio of scientific papers to patent applications over the past decade.1 Indeed, while research into AI began in earnest in the 1950s, more than 1.6 million scientific papers have been published on AI, with more than half of identified AI inventions in the last six years alone.2,3 A review article in Nature Medicine reported last year that despite few peer-reviewed publications on use of machine learning technologies in medical devices, FDA approvals of AI as medical devices have been accelerating.4 Many of these FDA approvals relate to image analysis for diagnostic purposes, such as QuantX, the first AI platform to evaluate breast abnormalities; Aidoc, which detects acute intracranial hemorrhages in head CT scans, assisting radiologists to prioritize patient injuries; and IDx-DR, which analyzes retinal images to detect diabetic retinopathy.
Sustainable Policy Making: A Strategic Challenge for Artificial Intelligence
Milano, Michela (University of Bologna) | OโSullivan, Barry (University College Cork) | Gavanelli, Marco (University of Ferrara)
Policy making is an extremely complex process occurring in changing environments and affecting the three pillars of sustainable development: society, economy and the environment. Each political decision in fact implies some form of social reactions, it affects economic and financial aspects and has substantial environmental impacts. Improving decision making in this context could have a huge beneficial impact on all these aspects. There are a number of Artificial Intelligence techniques that could play an important role in improving the policy making process such as decision support and optimization techniques, game theory, data and opinion mining and agent-based simulation. We outline here some potential use of AI technology as it emerged by the European Union (EU) EU FP7 project ePolicy: Engineering the Policy Making Life-Cycle, and we identify some potential research challenges.
Structured Estimation in Nonparameteric Cox Model
To better understand the interplay of censoring and sparsity we develop finite sample properties of nonparametric Cox proportional hazard's model. Due to high impact of sequencing data, carrying genetic information of each individual, we work with over-parametrized problem and propose general class of group penalties suitable for sparse structured variable selection and estimation. Novel non-asymptotic sandwich bounds for the partial likelihood are developed. We establish how they extend notion of local asymptotic normality (LAN) of Le Cam's. Such non-asymptotic LAN principles are further extended to high dimensional spaces where $p \gg n$. Finite sample prediction properties of penalized estimator in non-parametric Cox proportional hazards model, under suitable censoring conditions, agree with those of penalized estimator in linear models.
Scalable Bayesian Modelling of Paired Symbols
Paquet, Ulrich, Koenigstein, Noam, Winther, Ole
We present a novel, scalable and Bayesian approach to modelling the occurrence of pairs of symbols (i,j) drawn from a large vocabulary. Observed pairs are assumed to be generated by a simple popularity based selection process followed by censoring using a preference function. By basing inference on the well-founded principle of variational bounding, and using new site-independent bounds, we show how a scalable inference procedure can be obtained for large data sets. State of the art results are presented on real-world movie viewing data.
Arbitration and Stability in Cooperative Games with Overlapping Coalitions
Zick, Y., Markakis, E., Elkind, E.
Overlapping Coalition Formation (OCF) games, introduced by Chalkiadakis, Elkind, Markakis, Polukarov and Jennings in 2010, are cooperative games where players can simultaneously participate in several coalitions. Capturing the notion of stability in OCF games is a difficult task:deviating players may continue to contribute resources to joint projects with non-deviators, and the crucial question is what payoffs the deviators expect to receive from such projects. Chalkiadakis et al. introduce three stability concepts for OCF games---the conservative core, the refined core, and the optimistic core---that are based on different answers to this question. In this paper, we propose a unified framework for the study of stability in the OCF setting, which encompasses the stability concepts considered by Chalkiadakis et al. as well as a wide variety of alternative stability concepts. Our approach is based on the notion of arbitration functions, which determine the payoff obtained by the deviators, given their deviation and the current allocation of resources. We provide a characterization of stable outcomes under arbitration. We then conduct an in-depth study of four types of arbitration functions, which correspond to four notions of the core; these include the three notions of the core considered by Chalkiadakis et al. Our results complement those of Chalkiadakis et al. and answer questions left open by their work. In particular, we show that OCF games with the conservative arbitration function are essentially equivalent to non-OCF games, by relating the conservative core of an OCF game to the core of a non-overlapping cooperative game, and use this result to obtain a strictly weaker sufficient condition for conservative core non-emptiness than the one given by Chalkiadakis et al.