Law
Legal Summarisation through LLMs: The PRODIGIT Project
Pont, Thiago Dal, Galli, Federico, Loreggia, Andrea, Pisano, Giuseppe, Rovatti, Riccardo, Sartor, Giovanni
The law is typically a natural-language-based domain, and natural-language texts are pervasive in the law. First, natural language is the medium that legislation (including administrative regulations of all kinds) uses to express legal prescriptions, which humans (both experts and laypeople) are assumed to understand and comply with. Legislative and regulatory bodies have produced complex and evolving networks of natural language texts, which have complex structures and interconnections and use diverse terminologies to express technical and non-technical content. Second, natural language is used in judicial proceedings and opinions. In a proceeding, the parties to a legal case rely on natural language to express their arguments, motions, and claims, as do witnesses in their testimonies.
Unravelling Responsibility for AI
Porter, Zoe, Al-Qaddoumi, Joanna, Conmy, Philippa Ryan, Morgan, Phillip, McDermid, John, Habli, Ibrahim
To reason about where responsibility does and should lie in complex situations involving AI-enabled systems, we first need a sufficiently clear and detailed cross-disciplinary vocabulary for talking about responsibility. Responsibility is a triadic relation involving an actor, an occurrence, and a way of being responsible. As part of a conscious effort towards 'unravelling' the concept of responsibility to support practical reasoning about responsibility for AI, this paper takes the three-part formulation, 'Actor A is responsible for Occurrence O' and identifies valid combinations of subcategories of A, is responsible for, and O. These valid combinations - which we term "responsibility strings" - are grouped into four senses of responsibility: role-responsibility; causal responsibility; legal liability-responsibility; and moral responsibility. They are illustrated with two running examples, one involving a healthcare AI-based system and another the fatal collision of an AV with a pedestrian in Tempe, Arizona in 2018. The output of the paper is 81 responsibility strings. The aim is that these strings provide the vocabulary for people across disciplines to be clear and specific about the different ways that different actors are responsible for different occurrences within a complex event for which responsibility is sought, allowing for precise and targeted interdisciplinary normative deliberations.
AI4GCC-Team -- Below Sea Level: Score and Real World Relevance
Wozny, Phillip, Renting, Bram, Loftin, Robert, Wieners, Claudia, Acar, Erman
As our submission for track three of the AI for Global Climate Cooperation (AI4GCC) competition, we propose a negotiation protocol for use in the RICE-N climate-economic simulation. Our proposal seeks to address the challenges of carbon leakage through methods inspired by the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) and Climate Clubs (CC). We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach by comparing simulated outcomes to representative concentration pathways (RCP) and shared socioeconomic pathways (SSP). Our protocol results in a temperature rise comparable to RCP 3.4/4.5 and SSP 2. Furthermore, we provide an analysis of our protocol's World Trade Organization compliance, administrative and political feasibility, and ethical concerns. We recognize that our proposal risks hurting the least developing countries, and we suggest specific corrective measures to avoid exacerbating existing inequalities, such as technology sharing and wealth redistribution. Future research should improve the RICE-N tariff mechanism and implement actions allowing for the aforementioned corrective measures.
The flawed algorithm at the heart of Robodebt
Australia's Royal Commission into the Robodebt Scheme has published its findings. Various unnamed individuals are referred for potential civil or criminal investigation, but its publication is a timely reminder of the potential dangers presented by automated decision-making systems, and how the best way to mitigate their risks is by instilling a strong culture of ethics and systems for accountability in our institutions. The so-called Robodebt scheme was touted to save billions of dollars by using automation and algorithms to identify welfare fraud and overpayments. But in the end, it serves as a salient lesson in the dangers of replacing human oversight and judgement with automated decision-making. It reminds us that the basic method was not merely flawed but illegal; it was premised on the false belief of treating welfare recipients as cheats (rather than as society's most vulnerable); and it lacked both transparency and oversight.
Schumer should butt out of AI reg talks because of his 'familial ties' to big tech, say GOP groups
Fox News correspondent Gillian Turner has the latest on the president's focus amid calls for an impeachment inquiry on'Special Report.' EXCLUSIVE: Republican groups are calling on Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., to recuse himself from efforts to regulate artificial intelligence because of his daughters' work with Big Tech firms Meta and Amazon. Schumer has been leading a bipartisan group of senators that are examining guardrails for AI. But Republican groups Bull Moose Project and New York Young Republican Club, among other organizations, argued in a letter to Schumer that his family ties to these companies should disqualify him from the push to regulate AI. "As the Senate considers regulatory approaches to artificial intelligence (AI), it is crucial that lawmakers' personal conflicts of interest do not impact policy decisions," the representatives of the groups wrote. The groups said during last year's push to regulate Big Tech, some said the fact that his daughter Alison Schumer worked at Meta as a privacy and politics product marketing manager and his daughter Jessica Schumer was a registered Amazon lobbyist created a conflict of interest.
Model Provenance via Model DNA
Mu, Xin, Wang, Yu, Zhang, Yehong, Zhang, Jiaqi, Wang, Hui, Xiang, Yang, Yu, Yue
Understanding the life cycle of the machine learning (ML) model is an intriguing area of research (e.g., understanding where the model comes from, how it is trained, and how it is used). This paper focuses on a novel problem within this field, namely Model Provenance (MP), which concerns the relationship between a target model and its pre-training model and aims to determine whether a source model serves as the provenance for a target model. This is an important problem that has significant implications for ensuring the security and intellectual property of machine learning models but has not received much attention in the literature. To fill in this gap, we introduce a novel concept of Model DNA which represents the unique characteristics of a machine learning model. We utilize a data-driven and model-driven representation learning method to encode the model's training data and input-output information as a compact and comprehensive representation (i.e., DNA) of the model. Using this model DNA, we develop an efficient framework for model provenance identification, which enables us to identify whether a source model is a pre-training model of a target model. We conduct evaluations on both computer vision and natural language processing tasks using various models, datasets, and scenarios to demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in accurately identifying model provenance.
Supply chain emission estimation using large language models
Jain, Ayush, Padmanaban, Manikandan, Hazra, Jagabondhu, Godbole, Shantanu, Weldemariam, Kommy
Unfortunately, the world remains off track in meeting Development Goals (SDGs), especially goal 13, which focuses the Paris Agreement's target of limiting the temperature rise to on combating climate change and its impacts. To mitigate the effects 1.5 C above pre-industrial levels and reaching net-zero emissions of climate change, reducing enterprise Scope 3 (supply chain by 2050 [14], with a projected temperature rise of around 2.7 C emissions) is vital, as it accounts for more than 90% of total emission above pre-industrial levels by 2100 [22]. To achieve these targets, inventories. However, tracking Scope 3 emissions proves challenging, it is critical to engage non-state actors like enterprises, who have as data must be collected from thousands of upstream and pledged to reduce their GHG emissions, and have significant potential downstream suppliers. To address the above mentioned challenges, to drive more ambitious actions towards climate targets than we propose a first-of-a-kind framework that uses domain-adapted governments [9]. However, a lack of high-quality data and insights NLP foundation models to estimate Scope 3 emissions, by utilizing about an enterprise's operational performance can create barriers to financial transactions as a proxy for purchased goods and services.
Mapping ChatGPT in Mainstream Media to Unravel Jobs and Diversity Challenges: Early Quantitative Insights through Sentiment Analysis and Word Frequency Analysis
The exponential growth in user acquisition and popularity of OpenAIs ChatGPT, an artificial intelligence(AI) powered chatbot, was accompanied by widespread mainstream media coverage. This article presents a quantitative data analysis of the early trends and sentiments revealed by conducting text mining and NLP methods onto a corpus of 10,902 mainstream news headlines related to the subject of ChatGPT and artificial intelligence, from the launch of ChatGPT in November 2022 to March 2023. The findings revealed in sentiment analysis, ChatGPT and artificial intelligence, were perceived more positively than negatively in the mainstream media. In regards to word frequency results, over sixty-five percent of the top frequency words were focused on Big Tech issues and actors while topics such as jobs, diversity, ethics, copyright, gender and women were poorly represented or completely absent and only accounted for six percent of the total corpus. This article is a critical analysis into the power structures and collusions between Big Tech and Big Media in their hegemonic exclusion of diversity and job challenges from mainstream media.
Meaningful human command: Advance control directives as a method to enable moral and legal responsibility for autonomous weapons systems
21st Century war is increasing in speed, with conventional forces combined with massed use of autonomous systems and human-machine integration. However, a significant challenge is how humans can ensure moral and legal responsibility for systems operating outside of normal temporal parameters. This chapter considers whether humans can stand outside of real time and authorise actions for autonomous systems by the prior establishment of a contract, for actions to occur in a future context particularly in faster than real time or in very slow operations where human consciousness and concentration could not remain well informed. The medical legal precdent found in 'advance care directives' suggests how the time-consuming, deliberative process required for accountability and responsibility of weapons systems may be achievable outside real time captured in an 'advance control driective' (ACD). The chapter proposes 'autonomy command' scaffolded and legitimised through the construction of ACD ahead of the deployment of autonomous systems.
4 Charts That Show Why AI Progress Is Unlikely to Slow Down
In the last ten years, AI systems have developed at rapid speed. From the breakthrough of besting a legendary player at the complex game Go in 2016, AI is now able to recognize images and speech better than humans, and pass tests including business school exams and Amazon coding interview questions. Last week, during a U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee hearing about regulating AI, Senator Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut described the reaction of his constituents to recent advances in AI. "The word that has been used repeatedly is scary." The Subcommittee on Privacy, Technology, and the Law overseeing the meeting heard testimonies from three expert witnesses, who stressed the pace of progress in AI. One of those witnesses, Dario Amodei, CEO of prominent AI company Anthropic, said that "the single most important thing to understand about AI is how fast it is moving."