Country
Symbolic Probabilistic Reasoning for Narratives
Hajishirzi, Hannaneh (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign) | Mueller, Erik T. (IBM T. J. Watson)
We present a framework to represent and reason about narratives that combines logical and probabilistic representations of commonsense knowledge. Unlike most natural language understanding systems, which merely extract facts or semantic roles, our system builds probabilistic representations of the temporal sequence of world states and actions implied by a narrative. We use probabilistic actions to represent ambiguities and uncertainties in the narrative. We present algorithms that take a representation of a narrative, derive all possible interpretations of the narrative, and answer probabilistic queries by marginalizing over all the interpretations. With a focus on spatial contexts, we demonstrate our framework on an example narrative. To this end, we apply natural language pro- cessing (NLP) tools together with statistical approaches over common sense knowledge bases.
Understanding Robocup-Soccer Narratives
Hajishirzi, Hannaneh (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign) | Amir, Eyal (University of Illinios at Urbana-Champaign)
We present an approach to map Robocup-soccer narratives (in natural language) to a sequence of meaningful events. Our approach takes advantage of an action-centered framework, an inference subroutine, and an iterative learning algorithm. Our framework represents the narrative as a sequence of sentences and each sentence as a probability distribution over deterministic events. Our learning algorithm maps sentences to meaningful events without any annotated labeled data. Instead, it uses a prior knowledge about event descriptions and an inference subroutine to estimate initial training labels. The algorithm further improves the training labels at next iterations. In our experiments we demonstrate that with no labeled data our algorithm achieves higher accuracy compared to the state of the art that uses labeled data.
The Formalization of Practical Reasoning: An Opinionated Survey
Thomason, Richmond (University of Michigan)
I begin by considering examples of practical reasoning. In the remainder of the paper, I try to say something about what Example 8. Playing soccer. Soccer is like table tennis, but a logical approach that begins to do justice to the subject with the added dimension of teamwork and the need to might be like. This task was selected as a benchmark problem in robotics, and has been extensively Example 1. Ordering a meal at a restaurant. Here, the problem is deciding what to eat and drink. Typing an email message, Even if the only relevant factors are price and preferences composing it as you go along, starts perhaps with a general about food, the number of possible combinations is very idea of what to say.
The Counting Problem in the Light of Role Kinds
Masolo, Claudio (Laboratory for Applied Ontology, ISTC-CNR) | Vieu, Laure (IRIT-CNRS) | Kitamura, Yoshinobu (ISIR, Osaka University) | Kozaki, Kouji (ISIR, Osaka University) | Mizoguchi, Riichiro (ISIR, Osaka University)
Starting from a general characterization of roles, we focus on the ways in which roles are specified, we examine the formal constraints on their definitions, and propose definitional schemas motivating different kinds of roles. This classification, in addition to clarify the notion of role itself, helps us to reconsider the two standard solutions that have been proposed for the famous counting problem, and to suggest that a third mixed approach may be considered.
Causal Theories of Actions Revisited
Lin, Fangzhen (HKUST) | Soutchanski, Mikhail (Ryerson University)
It has been argued that causal rules are necessary for representing both implicit side-effects of actions and action qualifications, and there have been a number different approaches for representing causal rules in the area of formal theories of actions. These different approaches in general agree on rules without cycles. However, they differ on causal rules with mutual cyclic dependencies, both in terms of how these rules are supposed to be represented and their semantics. In this paper we show that by adding one more minimization to Lin's circumscriptive causal theory in the situation calculus, we can have a uniform representation of causal rules including those with cyclic dependencies. We also demonstrate that sometimes causal rules can be compiled into logically equivalent (under a proposed semantics) successor state axioms even in the presence of cyclical dependencies between fluents.
Representing Biological Processes in Modular Action Language ALM
Inclezan, Daniela (Texas Tech University) | Gelfond, Michael (Texas Tech University)
This paper presents the formalization of a biological process, cell division, in modular action language ALM. We show how the features of ALM — modularity, separation between an uninterpreted theory and its interpretation — lead to a simple and elegant solution that can be used in answering questions from biology textbooks.
A Naive Theory of Dimension for Qualitative Spatial Relations
Hahmann, Torsten (University of Toronto) | Gruninger, Michael (University of Toronto)
We present an ontology consisting of a theory of spatial dimension and a theory of dimension-independent mereological and topological relations in space. Though both are fairly weak axiomatizations, their interplay suffices to define various mereotopological relations and to make any necessary dimension constraints explicit. We show that models of the INCH Calculus and the Region-Connection Calculus (RCC) can be obtained from extensions of the proposed ontology.
Logic Programs and Causal Proofs
Cabalar, Pedro (University of Corunna)
In this work, we present a causal extension of logic programming under the stable models semantics where, for a given stable model, we capture the alternative causes of each true atom. The syntax is extended by the simple addition of an optional reference label per each rule in the program. Then, the obtained causes rely on the concept of a causal proof: an inverted tree of labels that keeps track of the ordered application of rules that has allowed deriving a given true atom.
Possible Worlds and Possible Meanings: A Semantics for the Interpretation of Vague Languages
Bennett, Brandon ( University of Leeds )
The paper develops a formal model for interpreting vague languages based on a variant of "supervaluation" semantics. Two modes of semantic variability are modelled, corresponding to different aspects of vagueness: one mode arises where there can be multiple definitions of a term; and the other relates to the threshold of applicability of a vague term with respect to the magnitude of relevant observable values. The truth of a proposition depends on both the possible world and the "precisification" with respect to which it is evaluated. Structures representing possible worlds and precisifications are both specified in terms of primitive functions representing observable measurements, so that the semantics is grounded upon an underlying theory of physical reality. On the basis of this semantics, the acceptability of a proposition to an agent is characterised in terms of a combination of agent's beliefs about the world and their attitude to admissible interpretations of vague predicates.
Housekeeping with Multiple Autonomous Robots: Representation, Reasoning and Execution
Aker, Erdi (Sabanci University) | Erdogan, Ahmetcan (Sabanci University) | Erdem, Esra (Sabanci University) | Patoglu, Volkan (Sabanci University)
We formalize actions and change in a housekeeping domain with multiple cleaning robots, and commonsense knowledge about this domain, in the action language C+. Geometric reasoning is lifted to high-level representation by embedding motion planning in the domain description using external predicates. With such a formalization of the domain, a plan can be computed using the causal reasoner CCalc for each robot to tidy some part of the house. We introduce a planning and monitoring algorithm for safe execution of these plans, so that it can recover from plan failures due to collision with movable objects whose presence and location are not known in advance or due to heavy objects that cannot be lifted alone. We illustrate the applicability of this algorithm with a simulation of a housekeeping domain.