South America
From Individual Experience to Collective Evidence: A Reporting-Based Framework for Identifying Systemic Harms
Dai, Jessica, Gradu, Paula, Raji, Inioluwa Deborah, Recht, Benjamin
When an individual reports a negative interaction with some system, how can their personal experience be contextualized within broader patterns of system behavior? We study the incident database problem, where individual reports of adverse events arrive sequentially, and are aggregated over time. In this work, our goal is to identify whether there are subgroups--defined by any combination of relevant features--that are disproportionately likely to experience harmful interactions with the system. We formalize this problem as a sequential hypothesis test, and identify conditions on reporting behavior that are sufficient for making inferences about disparities in true rates of harm across subgroups. We show that algorithms for sequential hypothesis tests can be applied to this problem with a standard multiple testing correction. We then demonstrate our method on real-world datasets, including mortgage decisions and vaccine side effects; on each, our method (re-)identifies subgroups known to experience disproportionate harm using only a fraction of the data that was initially used to discover them.
LLMs in Software Security: A Survey of Vulnerability Detection Techniques and Insights
Sheng, Ze, Chen, Zhicheng, Gu, Shuning, Huang, Heqing, Gu, Guofei, Huang, Jeff
Large Language Models (LLMs) are emerging as transformative tools for software vulnerability detection, addressing critical challenges in the security domain. Traditional methods, such as static and dynamic analysis, often falter due to inefficiencies, high false positive rates, and the growing complexity of modern software systems. By leveraging their ability to analyze code structures, identify patterns, and generate repair sugges- tions, LLMs, exemplified by models like GPT, BERT, and CodeBERT, present a novel and scalable approach to mitigating vulnerabilities. This paper provides a detailed survey of LLMs in vulnerability detection. It examines key aspects, including model architectures, application methods, target languages, fine-tuning strategies, datasets, and evaluation metrics. We also analyze the scope of current research problems, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of existing approaches. Further, we address challenges such as cross-language vulnerability detection, multimodal data integration, and repository-level analysis. Based on these findings, we propose solutions for issues like dataset scalability, model interpretability, and applications in low-resource scenarios. Our contributions are threefold: (1) a systematic review of how LLMs are applied in vulnerability detection; (2) an analysis of shared patterns and differences across studies, with a unified framework for understanding the field; and (3) a summary of key challenges and future research directions. This work provides valuable insights for advancing LLM-based vulnerability detection. We also maintain and regularly update latest selected paper on https://github.com/OwenSanzas/LLM-For-Vulnerability-Detection
Closer through commonality: Enhancing hypergraph contrastive learning with shared groups
Roh, Daeyoung, Han, Donghee, Kim, Daehee, Han, Keejun, Yi, Mun
Hypergraphs provide a superior modeling framework for representing complex multidimensional relationships in the context of real-world interactions that often occur in groups, overcoming the limitations of traditional homogeneous graphs. However, there have been few studies on hypergraphbased contrastive learning, and existing graph-based contrastive learning methods have not been able to fully exploit the highorder correlation information in hypergraphs. Here, we propose a Hypergraph Fine-grained contrastive learning (HyFi) method designed to exploit the complex high-dimensional information inherent in hypergraphs. While avoiding traditional graph augmentation methods that corrupt the hypergraph topology, the proposed method provides a simple and efficient learning augmentation function by adding noise to node features. Furthermore, we expands beyond the traditional dichotomous relationship between positive and negative samples in contrastive learning by introducing a new relationship of weak positives. It demonstrates the importance of fine-graining positive samples in contrastive learning. Therefore, HyFi is able to produce highquality embeddings, and outperforms both supervised and unsupervised baselines in average rank on node classification across 10 datasets. Our approach effectively exploits high-dimensional hypergraph information, shows significant improvement over existing graph-based contrastive learning methods, and is efficient in terms of training speed and GPU memory cost. The source code is available at https://github.com/Noverse0/HyFi.git.
Are Expressions for Music Emotions the Same Across Cultures?
Celen, Elif, van Rijn, Pol, Lee, Harin, Jacoby, Nori
Music evokes profound emotions, yet the universality of emotional descriptors across languages remains debated. A key challenge in cross-cultural research on music emotion is biased stimulus selection and manual curation of taxonomies, predominantly relying on Western music and languages. To address this, we propose a balanced experimental design with nine online experiments in Brazil, the US, and South Korea, involving N=672 participants. First, we sample a balanced set of popular music from these countries. Using an open-ended tagging pipeline, we then gather emotion terms to create culture-specific taxonomies. Finally, using these bottom-up taxonomies, participants rate emotions of each song. This allows us to map emotional similarities within and across cultures. Results show consistency in high arousal, high valence emotions but greater variability in others. Notably, machine translations were often inadequate to capture music-specific meanings. These findings together highlight the need for a domain-sensitive, open-ended, bottom-up emotion elicitation approach to reduce cultural biases in emotion research.
InTAR: Inter-Task Auto-Reconfigurable Accelerator Design for High Data Volume Variation in DNNs
He, Zifan, Truong, Anderson, Cao, Yingqi, Cong, Jason
The rise of deep neural networks (DNNs) has driven a boom in AI services, which results in an increased demand for computing power and memory. In modern DNNs, the data sizes produced and consumed are highly varied across operations (high data volume variation, HDV). Because existing design paradigms use fixed execution patterns that lead to either low computational efficiency due to pipeline stalls or frequent off-chip memory accesses to manage large intermediate data, HDV applications are challenging to accelerate on FPGAs. To address these challenges, we introduce the Inter-Task Auto-Reconfigurable Accelerator (InTAR), a novel accelerator design for HDV applications on FPGAs. InTAR combines the high computational efficiency of sequential execution with the reduced off-chip memory overhead of dataflow execution. It switches execution patterns automatically with a static schedule determined before circuit design based on resource constraints and model parameters. Unlike previous reconfigurable accelerators, InTAR encodes reconfiguration schedules during circuit design, allowing model-specific optimizations that allocate only the necessary logic and interconnects. Thus, InTAR achieves a high clock frequency with fewer resources and low reconfiguration time. Furthermore, InTAR supports high-level tools such as HLS for fast design generation. We implement a set of multi-task kernels in various HDV DNNs using InTAR. Compared with dataflow and sequential accelerators, InTAR exhibits $1.8\times$ and $7.1 \times$ speedups correspondingly. We also implement InTAR for GPT-2 medium as a more complex example, which achieves a speedup of $\mathbf{3.65 \sim 39.14\times}$ and a $\mathbf{1.72 \sim 10.44\times}$ boost in DSP efficiency compared to the corresponding SoTA accelerators on FPGAs.
AutoLike: Auditing Social Media Recommendations through User Interactions
Le, Hieu, Elmalaki, Salma, Shafiq, Zubair, Markopoulou, Athina
Modern social media platforms, such as TikTok, Facebook, and YouTube, rely on recommendation systems to personalize content for users based on user interactions with endless streams of content, such as "For You" pages. However, these complex algorithms can inadvertently deliver problematic content related to self-harm, mental health, and eating disorders. We introduce AutoLike, a framework to audit recommendation systems in social media platforms for topics of interest and their sentiments. To automate the process, we formulate the problem as a reinforcement learning problem. AutoLike drives the recommendation system to serve a particular type of content through interactions (e.g., liking). We apply the AutoLike framework to the TikTok platform as a case study. We evaluate how well AutoLike identifies TikTok content automatically across nine topics of interest; and conduct eight experiments to demonstrate how well it drives TikTok's recommendation system towards particular topics and sentiments. AutoLike has the potential to assist regulators in auditing recommendation systems for problematic content. (Warning: This paper contains qualitative examples that may be viewed as offensive or harmful.)
ZETA: Leveraging Z-order Curves for Efficient Top-k Attention
Zeng, Qiuhao, Huang, Jerry, Lu, Peng, Xu, Gezheng, Chen, Boxing, Ling, Charles, Wang, Boyu
Over recent years, the Transformer has become a fundamental building block for sequence modeling architectures. Yet at its core is the use of self-attention, whose memory and computational cost grow quadratically with the sequence length $N$, rendering it prohibitively expensive for long sequences. A promising approach is top-$k$ attention, which selects only the $k$ most relevant tokens and achieves performance comparable to vanilla self-attention while significantly reducing space and computational demands. However, causal masks require the current query token to only attend to past tokens, preventing the existing top-$k$ attention method from efficiently searching for the most relevant tokens in parallel, thereby limiting training efficiency. In this work, we propose ZETA, leveraging \textbf{Z}-Order Curves for \textbf{E}fficient \textbf{T}op-$k$ \textbf{A}ttention, to enable parallel querying of past tokens for entire sequences. % in both space and time complexity of $\mathcal{O}(N \log N)$. We first theoretically show that the choice of key and query dimensions involves a trade-off between the curse of dimensionality and the preservation of relative distances after projection. In light of this insight, we propose reducing the dimensionality of keys and queries in contrast to values and further leverage $Z$-order curves to map low-dimensional keys and queries into \emph{one}-dimensional space, which permits parallel sorting, thereby largely improving the efficiency for top-$k$ token selection. Experimental results demonstrate that ZETA matches the performance of standard attention on the synthetic \textsc{Multi-Query Associative Recall} task and outperforms attention and its variants on \textsc{Long Range Arena} and \textsc{WikiText-103} language modeling.
Treatment response as a latent variable
Tosh, Christopher, Zhang, Boyuan, Tansey, Wesley
Scientists often need to analyze the samples in a study that responded to treatment in order to refine their hypotheses and find potential causal drivers of response. Natural variation in outcomes makes teasing apart responders from non-responders a statistical inference problem. To handle latent responses, we introduce the causal two-groups (C2G) model, a causal extension of the classical two-groups model. The C2G model posits that treated samples may or may not experience an effect, according to some prior probability. We propose two empirical Bayes procedures for the causal two-groups model, one under semi-parametric conditions and another under fully nonparametric conditions. The semi-parametric model assumes additive treatment effects and is identifiable from observed data. The nonparametric model is unidentifiable, but we show it can still be used to test for response in each treated sample. We show empirically and theoretically that both methods for selecting responders control the false discovery rate at the target level with near-optimal power. We also propose two novel estimands of interest and provide a strategy for deriving estimand intervals in the unidentifiable nonparametric model. On a cancer immunotherapy dataset, the nonparametric C2G model recovers clinically-validated predictive biomarkers of both positive and negative outcomes. Code is available at https://github.com/tansey-lab/causal2groups.
Linear-Time User-Level DP-SCO via Robust Statistics
Ghazi, Badih, Kumar, Ravi, Liu, Daogao, Manurangsi, Pasin
User-level differentially private stochastic convex optimization (DP-SCO) has garnered significant attention due to the paramount importance of safeguarding user privacy in modern large-scale machine learning applications. Current methods, such as those based on differentially private stochastic gradient descent (DP-SGD), often struggle with high noise accumulation and suboptimal utility due to the need to privatize every intermediate iterate. In this work, we introduce a novel linear-time algorithm that leverages robust statistics, specifically the median and trimmed mean, to overcome these challenges. Our approach uniquely bounds the sensitivity of all intermediate iterates of SGD with gradient estimation based on robust statistics, thereby significantly reducing the gradient estimation noise for privacy purposes and enhancing the privacy-utility trade-off. By sidestepping the repeated privatization required by previous methods, our algorithm not only achieves an improved theoretical privacy-utility trade-off but also maintains computational efficiency. We complement our algorithm with an information-theoretic lower bound, showing that our upper bound is optimal up to logarithmic factors and the dependence on $\epsilon$. This work sets the stage for more robust and efficient privacy-preserving techniques in machine learning, with implications for future research and application in the field.
Humanity's Last Exam
Phan, Long, Gatti, Alice, Han, Ziwen, Li, Nathaniel, Hu, Josephina, Zhang, Hugh, Zhang, Chen Bo Calvin, Shaaban, Mohamed, Ling, John, Shi, Sean, Choi, Michael, Agrawal, Anish, Chopra, Arnav, Khoja, Adam, Kim, Ryan, Ren, Richard, Hausenloy, Jason, Zhang, Oliver, Mazeika, Mantas, Nguyen, Tung, Anderson, Daron, Shah, Imad Ali, Doroshenko, Mikhail, Stokes, Alun Cennyth, Mahmood, Mobeen, Lee, Jaeho, Pokutnyi, Oleksandr, Iskra, Oleg, Wang, Jessica P., Gerbicz, Robert, Levin, John-Clark, Popov, Serguei, Feng, Fiona, Feng, Steven Y., Zhao, Haoran, Yu, Michael, Gangal, Varun, Zou, Chelsea, Wang, Zihan, Kazakov, Mstyslav, Galgon, Geoff, Schmitt, Johannes, Sanchez, Alvaro, Lee, Yongki, Yeadon, Will, Sauers, Scott, Roth, Marc, Agu, Chidozie, Riis, Søren, Giska, Fabian, Utpala, Saiteja, Cheatom, Antrell, Giboney, Zachary, Goshu, Gashaw M., Crowson, Sarah-Jane, Naiya, Mohinder Maheshbhai, Burns, Noah, Finke, Lennart, Cheng, Zerui, Park, Hyunwoo, Fournier-Facio, Francesco, Zampese, Jennifer, Wydallis, John, Wydallis, John B., Hoerr, Ryan G., Nandor, Mark, Gehrunger, Tim, Cai, Jiaqi, McCarty, Ben, Nam, Jungbae, Taylor, Edwin, Jin, Jun, Loume, Gautier Abou, Cao, Hangrui, Garretson, Alexis C, Sileo, Damien, Ren, Qiuyu, Cojoc, Doru, Arkhipov, Pavel, Qazi, Usman, Bacho, Aras, Li, Lianghui, Motwani, Sumeet, de Witt, Christian Schroeder, Kopylov, Alexei, Veith, Johannes, Singer, Eric, Rissone, Paolo, Jin, Jaehyeok, Shi, Jack Wei Lun, Willcocks, Chris G., Prabhu, Ameya, Tang, Longke, Zhou, Kevin, Santos, Emily de Oliveira, Maksimov, Andrey Pupasov, Vendrow, Edward, Zenitani, Kengo, Robinson, Joshua, Mikov, Aleksandar, Guillod, Julien, Li, Yuqi, Pageler, Ben, Vendrow, Joshua, Kuchkin, Vladyslav, Marion, Pierre, Efremov, Denis, Lynch, Jayson, Liang, Kaiqu, Gritsevskiy, Andrew, Martinez, Dakotah, Crispino, Nick, Zvonkine, Dimitri, Fraga, Natanael Wildner, Soori, Saeed, Press, Ori, Tang, Henry, Salazar, Julian, Green, Sean R., Brüssel, Lina, Twayana, Moon, Dieuleveut, Aymeric, Rogers, T. Ryan, Zhang, Wenjin, Finocchio, Ross, Li, Bikun, Yang, Jinzhou, Rao, Arun, Loiseau, Gabriel, Kalinin, Mikhail, Lukas, Marco, Manolescu, Ciprian, Stambaugh, Nate, Mishra, Subrata, Kamdoum, Ariel Ghislain Kemogne, Hogg, Tad, Jin, Alvin, Bosio, Carlo, Sun, Gongbo, Coppola, Brian P, Heidinger, Haline, Sayous, Rafael, Ivanov, Stefan, Cavanagh, Joseph M, Shen, Jiawei, Imperial, Joseph Marvin, Schwaller, Philippe, Senthilkuma, Shaipranesh, Bran, Andres M, Algaba, Andres, Verbeken, Brecht, Houte, Kelsey Van den, Van Der Sypt, Lynn, Noever, David, Schut, Lisa, Sucholutsky, Ilia, Zheltonozhskii, Evgenii, Yuan, Qiaochu, Lim, Derek, Stanley, Richard, Sivarajan, Shankar, Yang, Tong, Maar, John, Wykowski, Julian, Oller, Martí, Sandlin, Jennifer, Sahu, Anmol, Ardito, Cesare Giulio, Hu, Yuzheng, Dias, Felipe Meneguitti, Kreiman, Tobias, Rawal, Kaivalya, Vilchis, Tobias Garcia, Zu, Yuexuan, Lackner, Martin, Koppel, James, Nguyen, Jeremy, Antonenko, Daniil S., Chern, Steffi, Zhao, Bingchen, Arsene, Pierrot, Ivanov, Sergey, Poświata, Rafał, Wang, Chenguang, Li, Daofeng, Crisostomi, Donato, Dehghan, Ali, Achilleos, Andrea, Ambay, John Arnold, Myklebust, Benjamin, Sen, Archan, Perrella, David, Kaparov, Nurdin, Inlow, Mark H, Zang, Allen, Ramakrishnan, Kalyan, Orel, Daniil, Poritski, Vladislav, Ben-David, Shalev, Berger, Zachary, Whitfill, Parker, Foster, Michael, Munro, Daniel, Ho, Linh, Hava, Dan Bar, Kuchkin, Aleksey, Lauff, Robert, Holmes, David, Sommerhage, Frank, Zhang, Anji, Moat, Richard, Schneider, Keith, Pyda, Daniel, Kazibwe, Zakayo, Singh, Mukhwinder, Clarke, Don, Kim, Dae Hyun, Fish, Sara, Elser, Veit, Vilchis, Victor Efren Guadarrama, Klose, Immo, Demian, Christoph, Anantheswaran, Ujjwala, Zweiger, Adam, Albani, Guglielmo, Li, Jeffery, Daans, Nicolas, Radionov, Maksim, Rozhoň, Václav, Ginis, Vincent, Ma, Ziqiao, Stump, Christian, Platnick, Jacob, Nevirkovets, Volodymyr, Basler, Luke, Piccardo, Marco, Cohen, Niv, Singh, Virendra, Tkadlec, Josef, Rosu, Paul, Goldfarb, Alan, Padlewski, Piotr, Barzowski, Stanislaw, Montgomery, Kyle, Menezes, Aline, Patel, Arkil, Wang, Zixuan, Tucker-Foltz, Jamie, Stade, Jack, Grabb, Declan, Goertzen, Tom, Kazemi, Fereshteh, Milbauer, Jeremiah, Shukla, Abhishek, Elgnainy, Hossam, Labrador, Yan Carlos Leyva, He, Hao, Zhang, Ling, Givré, Alan, Wolff, Hew, Demir, Gözdenur, Aziz, Muhammad Fayez, Kaddar, Younesse, Ängquist, Ivar, Chen, Yanxu, Thornley, Elliott, Zhang, Robin, Pan, Jiayi, Terpin, Antonio, Muennighoff, Niklas, Schoelkopf, Hailey, Zheng, Eric, Carmi, Avishy, Shah, Jainam, Brown, Ethan D. L., Zhu, Kelin, Bartolo, Max, Wheeler, Richard, Ho, Andrew, Barkan, Shaul, Wang, Jiaqi, Stehberger, Martin, Kretov, Egor, Bradshaw, Peter, Heimonen, JP, Sridhar, Kaustubh, Hossain, Zaki, Akov, Ido, Makarychev, Yury, Tam, Joanna, Hoang, Hieu, Cunningham, David M., Goryachev, Vladimir, Patramanis, Demosthenes, Krause, Michael, Redenti, Andrew, Aldous, David, Lai, Jesyin, Coleman, Shannon, Xu, Jiangnan, Lee, Sangwon, Magoulas, Ilias, Zhao, Sandy, Tang, Ning, Cohen, Michael K., Carroll, Micah, Paradise, Orr, Kirchner, Jan Hendrik, Steinerberger, Stefan, Ovchynnikov, Maksym, Matos, Jason O., Shenoy, Adithya, Wang, Michael, Nie, Yuzhou, Giordano, Paolo, Petersen, Philipp, Sztyber-Betley, Anna, Faraboschi, Paolo, Riblet, Robin, Crozier, Jonathan, Halasyamani, Shiv, Pinto, Antonella, Verma, Shreyas, Joshi, Prashant, Meril, Eli, Yong, Zheng-Xin, Tee, Allison, Andréoletti, Jérémy, Weller, Orion, Singhal, Raghav, Zhang, Gang, Ivanov, Alexander, Khoury, Seri, Gustafsson, Nils, Mostaghimi, Hamid, Thaman, Kunvar, Chen, Qijia, Khánh, Tran Quoc, Loader, Jacob, Cavalleri, Stefano, Szlyk, Hannah, Brown, Zachary, Narayan, Himanshu, Roberts, Jonathan, Alley, William, Sun, Kunyang, Stendall, Ryan, Lamparth, Max, Reuel, Anka, Wang, Ting, Xu, Hanmeng, Hernández-Cámara, Pablo, Martin, Freddie, Preu, Thomas, Korbak, Tomek, Abramovitch, Marcus, Williamson, Dominic, Bosio, Ida, Chen, Ziye, Bálint, Biró, Lo, Eve J. Y., Nunes, Maria Inês S., Jiang, Yibo, Bari, M Saiful, Kassani, Peyman, Wang, Zihao, Ansarinejad, Behzad, Sun, Yewen, Durand, Stephane, Douville, Guillaume, Tordera, Daniel, Balabanian, George, Anderson, Earth, Kvistad, Lynna, Moyano, Alejandro José, Milliron, Hsiaoyun, Sakor, Ahmad, Eron, Murat, McAlister, Isaac C., O., Andrew Favre D., Shah, Shailesh, Zhou, Xiaoxiang, Kamalov, Firuz, Clark, Ronald, Abdoli, Sherwin, Santens, Tim, Wang, Harrison K, Chen, Evan, Tomasiello, Alessandro, De Luca, G. Bruno, Looi, Shi-Zhuo, Le, Vinh-Kha, Kolt, Noam, Mündler, Niels, Semler, Avi, Rodman, Emma, Drori, Jacob, Fossum, Carl J, Gloor, Luk, Jagota, Milind, Pradeep, Ronak, Fan, Honglu, Shah, Tej, Eicher, Jonathan, Chen, Michael, Thaman, Kushal, Merrill, William, Firsching, Moritz, Harris, Carter, Ciobâcă, Stefan, Gross, Jason, Pandey, Rohan, Gusev, Ilya, Jones, Adam, Agnihotri, Shashank, Zhelnov, Pavel, Usawasutsakorn, Siranut, Mofayezi, Mohammadreza, Piperski, Alexander, Carauleanu, Marc, Zhang, David K., Dobarskyi, Kostiantyn, Ler, Dylan, Leventov, Roman, Soroko, Ignat, Jansen, Thorben, Creighton, Scott, Lauer, Pascal, Duersch, Joshua, Taamazyan, Vage, Bezzi, Dario, Morak, Wiktor, Ma, Wenjie, Held, William, Huy, Tran Đuc, Xian, Ruicheng, Zebaze, Armel Randy, Mohamed, Mohanad, Leser, Julian Noah, Yuan, Michelle X, Yacar, Laila, Lengler, Johannes, Olszewska, Katarzyna, Shahrtash, Hossein, Oliveira, Edson, Jackson, Joseph W., Gonzalez, Daniel Espinosa, Zou, Andy, Chidambaram, Muthu, Manik, Timothy, Haffenden, Hector, Stander, Dashiell, Dasouqi, Ali, Shen, Alexander, Duc, Emilien, Golshani, Bita, Stap, David, Uzhou, Mikalai, Zhidkovskaya, Alina Borisovna, Lewark, Lukas, Rodriguez, Miguel Orbegozo, Vincze, Mátyás, Wehr, Dustin, Tang, Colin, Phillips, Shaun, Samuele, Fortuna, Muzhen, Jiang, Ekström, Fredrik, Hammon, Angela, Patel, Oam, Farhidi, Faraz, Medley, George, Mohammadzadeh, Forough, Peñaflor, Madellene, Kassahun, Haile, Friedrich, Alena, Sparrow, Claire, Perez, Rayner Hernandez, Sakal, Taom, Dhamane, Omkar, Mirabadi, Ali Khajegili, Hallman, Eric, Okutsu, Kenchi, Battaglia, Mike, Maghsoudimehrabani, Mohammad, Amit, Alon, Hulbert, Dave, Pereira, Roberto, Weber, Simon, Handoko, null, Peristyy, Anton, Malina, Stephen, Albanie, Samuel, Cai, Will, Mehkary, Mustafa, Aly, Rami, Reidegeld, Frank, Dick, Anna-Katharina, Friday, Cary, Sidhu, Jasdeep, Shapourian, Hassan, Kim, Wanyoung, Costa, Mariana, Gurdogan, Hubeyb, Weber, Brian, Kumar, Harsh, Jiang, Tong, Agarwal, Arunim, Ceconello, Chiara, Vaz, Warren S., Zhuang, Chao, Park, Haon, Tawfeek, Andrew R., Aggarwal, Daattavya, Kirchhof, Michael, Dai, Linjie, Kim, Evan, Ferret, Johan, Wang, Yuzhou, Yan, Minghao, Burdzy, Krzysztof, Zhang, Lixin, Franca, Antonio, Pham, Diana T., Loh, Kang Yong, Robinson, Joshua, Jackson, Abram, Gul, Shreen, Chhablani, Gunjan, Du, Zhehang, Cosma, Adrian, Colino, Jesus, White, Colin, Votava, Jacob, Vinnikov, Vladimir, Delaney, Ethan, Spelda, Petr, Stritecky, Vit, Shahid, Syed M., Mourrat, Jean-Christophe, Vetoshkin, Lavr, Sponselee, Koen, Bacho, Renas, de la Rosa, Florencia, Li, Xiuyu, Malod, Guillaume, Lang, Leon, Laurendeau, Julien, Kazakov, Dmitry, Adesanya, Fatimah, Portier, Julien, Hollom, Lawrence, Souza, Victor, Zhou, Yuchen Anna, Degorre, Julien, Yalın, Yiğit, Obikoya, Gbenga Daniel, Arnaboldi, Luca, Rai, null, Bigi, Filippo, Boscá, M. C., Shumar, Oleg, Bacho, Kaniuar, Clavier, Pierre, Recchia, Gabriel, Popescu, Mara, Shulga, Nikita, Tanwie, Ngefor Mildred, Peskoff, Denis, Lux, Thomas C. H., Rank, Ben, Ni, Colin, Brooks, Matthew, Yakimchyk, Alesia, Huanxu, null, Liu, null, Häggström, Olle, Verkama, Emil, Gundlach, Hans, Brito-Santana, Leonor, Amaro, Brian, Vajipey, Vivek, Grover, Rynaa, Fan, Yiyang, Silva, Gabriel Poesia Reis e, Xin, Linwei, Kratish, Yosi, Łucki, Jakub, Li, Wen-Ding, Gopi, Sivakanth, Caciolai, Andrea, Xu, Justin, Scaria, Kevin Joseph, Vargus, Freddie, Habibi, Farzad, Long, null, Lian, null, Rodolà, Emanuele, Robins, Jules, Cheng, Vincent, Fruhauff, Tony, Raynor, Brad, Qi, Hao, Jiang, Xi, Segev, Ben, Fan, Jingxuan, Martinson, Sarah, Wang, Erik Y., Hausknecht, Kaylie, Brenner, Michael P., Mao, Mao, Zhang, Xinyu, Avagian, David, Scipio, Eshawn Jessica, Ragoler, Alon, Tan, Justin, Sims, Blake, Plecnik, Rebeka, Kirtland, Aaron, Bodur, Omer Faruk, Shinde, D. P., Adoul, Zahra, Zekry, Mohamed, Karakoc, Ali, Santos, Tania C. B., Shamseldeen, Samir, Karim, Loukmane, Liakhovitskaia, Anna, Resman, Nate, Farina, Nicholas, Gonzalez, Juan Carlos, Maayan, Gabe, Hoback, Sarah, Pena, Rodrigo De Oliveira, Sherman, Glen, Kelley, Elizabeth, Mariji, Hodjat, Pouriamanesh, Rasoul, Wu, Wentao, Mendoza, Sandra, Alarab, Ismail, Cole, Joshua, Ferreira, Danyelle, Johnson, Bryan, Safdari, Mohammad, Dai, Liangti, Arthornthurasuk, Siriphan, Pronin, Alexey, Fan, Jing, Ramirez-Trinidad, Angel, Cartwright, Ashley, Pottmaier, Daphiny, Taheri, Omid, Outevsky, David, Stepanic, Stanley, Perry, Samuel, Askew, Luke, Rodríguez, Raúl Adrián Huerta, Minissi, Ali M. R., Ali, Sam, Lorena, Ricardo, Iyer, Krishnamurthy, Fasiludeen, Arshad Anil, Salauddin, Sk Md, Islam, Murat, Gonzalez, Juan, Ducey, Josh, Somrak, Maja, Mavroudis, Vasilios, Vergo, Eric, Qin, Juehang, Borbás, Benjámin, Chu, Eric, Lindsey, Jack, Radhakrishnan, Anil, Jallon, Antoine, McInnis, I. M. J., Kumar, Pawan, Goswami, Laxman Prasad, Bugas, Daniel, Heydari, Nasser, Jeanplong, Ferenc, Apronti, Archimedes, Galal, Abdallah, Ze-An, Ng, Singh, Ankit, Xavier, Joan of Arc, Agarwal, Kanu Priya, Berkani, Mohammed, Junior, Benedito Alves de Oliveira, Malishev, Dmitry, Remy, Nicolas, Hartman, Taylor D., Tarver, Tim, Mensah, Stephen, Gimenez, Javier, Montecillo, Roselynn Grace, Campbell, Russell, Sharma, Asankhaya, Meer, Khalida, Alapont, Xavier, Patil, Deepakkumar, Maheshwari, Rajat, Dendane, Abdelkader, Shukla, Priti, Bogdanov, Sergei, Möller, Sören, Siddiqi, Muhammad Rehan, Saxena, Prajvi, Gupta, Himanshu, Enyekwe, Innocent, P, Ragavendran V, EL-Wasif, Zienab, Maksapetyan, Aleksandr, Rossbach, Vivien, Harjadi, Chris, Bahaloohoreh, Mohsen, Bian, Song, Lai, John, Uro, Justine Leon, Bateman, Greg, Sayed, Mohamed, Menshawy, Ahmed, Duclosel, Darling, Jain, Yashaswini, Aaron, Ashley, Tiryakioglu, Murat, Siddh, Sheeshram, Krenek, Keith, Hoover, Alex, McGowan, Joseph, Patwardhan, Tejal, Yue, Summer, Wang, Alexandr, Hendrycks, Dan
Benchmarks are important tools for tracking the rapid advancements in large language model (LLM) capabilities. However, benchmarks are not keeping pace in difficulty: LLMs now achieve over 90\% accuracy on popular benchmarks like MMLU, limiting informed measurement of state-of-the-art LLM capabilities. In response, we introduce Humanity's Last Exam (HLE), a multi-modal benchmark at the frontier of human knowledge, designed to be the final closed-ended academic benchmark of its kind with broad subject coverage. HLE consists of 3,000 questions across dozens of subjects, including mathematics, humanities, and the natural sciences. HLE is developed globally by subject-matter experts and consists of multiple-choice and short-answer questions suitable for automated grading. Each question has a known solution that is unambiguous and easily verifiable, but cannot be quickly answered via internet retrieval. State-of-the-art LLMs demonstrate low accuracy and calibration on HLE, highlighting a significant gap between current LLM capabilities and the expert human frontier on closed-ended academic questions. To inform research and policymaking upon a clear understanding of model capabilities, we publicly release HLE at https://lastexam.ai.